"Escarabajos" Who is the best climber?

Page 6 - Get up to date with the latest news, scores & standings from the Cycling News Community.

Whos the best climber?

  • Johan Chaves

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • Total voters
    0
Aug 23, 2012
1,114
1
0
Hugo Koblet said:
I might be wrong, but didn't Ulissi have a gap in GP Industria? In that case, it wouldn't really be correct to say that he beat Oss, Rebellin etc. in an uphill sprint.

I might be wrong though.

If im not wrong he made the gap in the final 300 metres... :)
 
Aug 23, 2012
1,114
1
0
greenedge said:
He has also won a GC stage. Maybe he will not get a co-leaders role now, but in the future he definitely should.
The leaders of Italy will be Nibali, Ulissi and Moser. Cunego, Gasparotto, Pozzato and Visconti wont be in Limburg. I think Diego and Moreno wont work for Paolini, Capecchi or Trentin:D
 
Quintana: "My goal is to win a Grand Tour"
http://www.as.com/ciclismo/articulo/objetivo-conquistar-grandes/20120907dasdaicic_5/Tes
objetivo_conquistar_grandes.jpg
 
Oct 16, 2010
379
0
0
yesterday, betancur won the queen stage of the monviso venezia, formerly the giro della padania beating in an uphill sprint pelizzotti rebellin nibali sella and atapuma among the others.
betancur was very strong at the end and he was able to come back on the leaders in the last 3 km ascent, while on the demanding colla del prel, which is very hard atapuma performed very well.
betancur knows how to win and he will be a factor in valkenburg. i do not know if going to the ag2r next year is the right choice, i would have preferred seeing him in the liquigas group.
atapuma proved to beon of the strongest climber. ha was able to stand pelizzotti and nibali rhythm on the colla del prel and he got clear in the last climb and he was caught with 350 mt to go. he has made considerable progress this year with corti and next year if he will stay with coldeportes and they are invited to gt, he will do great things in real mountain stages with long and steep climbs ( giro style not vuelta style..)
 
profff said:
yesterday, betancur won the queen stage of the monviso venezia, formerly the giro della padania beating in an uphill sprint pelizzotti rebellin nibali sella and atapuma among the others.
betancur was very strong at the end and he was able to come back on the leaders in the last 3 km ascent, while on the demanding colla del prel, which is very hard atapuma performed very well.
betancur knows how to win and he will be a factor in valkenburg. i do not know if going to the ag2r next year is the right choice, i would have preferred seeing him in the liquigas group.
atapuma proved to beon of the strongest climber. ha was able to stand pelizzotti and nibali rhythm on the colla del prel and he got clear in the last climb and he was caught with 350 mt to go. he has made considerable progress this year with corti and next year if he will stay with coldeportes and they are invited to gt, he will do great things in real mountain stages with long and steep climbs ( giro style not vuelta style..)

Yet he's still not consistent enough I think.
I watched both of the stages and while I concur Atapuma was great yesterday, he lost more than a minute the day before on Passo della Bocchetta. Don't know if he had any health issue or something, but I'm not sure he's ready for GC in a Giro. More of a stage hunter until he proves me wrong.

Betancur is an amazing talent. Really looking forward to see him in the Worlds.
 
Mar 31, 2010
18,136
6
0
SafeBet said:
Yet he's still not consistent enough I think.
I watched both of the stages and while I concur Atapuma was great yesterday, he lost more than a minute the day before on Passo della Bocchetta. Don't know if he had any health issue or something, but I'm not sure he's ready for GC in a Giro. More of a stage hunter until he proves me wrong.

Betancur is an amazing talent. Really looking forward to see him in the Worlds.

atapuma is inconcistant because he had a bad basis this winter. not as bad as the likes of duarte though, who are even more inconcistant. I wouldn't count on him being inconcistant next year when coldeported hopefully have learned from their mistakes
 
Aug 23, 2012
1,114
1
0
Atapuma is the improved version of Pérez Cuapio. Darwin will be the king of the Dolomites for many years:D He has the talent. I expect performances like Rujano in Giro 2005 or 2008, the man who mades top GC by breaks aways. I enjoy this kind of cycling:cool:
 
Dec 27, 2010
6,674
1
0
Yeah I can see Atapuma having a Perez Cuapio or Cardenas type role in GTs. Capable of winning stages from the front against the big guns but nowhere on GC.
 
Mar 31, 2010
18,136
6
0
will10 said:
Yeah I can see Atapuma having a Perez Cuapio or Cardenas type role in GTs. Capable of winning stages from the front against the big guns but nowhere on GC.

cardenas was the most steady gt rider in his good days. nothing like perez cuapio.
 
Aug 23, 2012
1,114
1
0
cineteq said:
Henao is thinking big. He loves the Giro and wants a podium place.

"Me gustaría volver mucho al Giro, aunque con ambiciones más grandes que las de este año en el que me sacrifiqué por Rigoberto. Quiero luchar por un podio. Sería mi gran objetivo y mi gran sueño."

http://biciciclismo.com/cas/site/noticias-ficha.asp?id=55535

I think is possible. We would need to see the riders who would participate. Next year probably Hesjedal will want win one more time, the Ag2r squad with Pozzovivo and Betancur, Movistar with Quintana and maybe Evans, Nibali or Fuglsang.
 
Aug 23, 2012
1,114
1
0
Also i want the TT's who didnt participate in this 2012. Guys like Van Garderen, Talansky or Brajkovic. Of course i want a route with two ITTS. Would be an interesting battle between climbers and time triallists.
 
Mar 31, 2010
18,136
6
0
Jason_Mercier said:
Also i want the TT's who didnt participate in this 2012. Guys like Van Garderen, Talansky or Brajkovic. Of course i want a route with two ITTS. Would be an interesting battle between climbers and time triallists.

I agree. I really want 2 long flat itt's in a giro like there used to be.
 
Apr 14, 2011
998
0
0
Jason_Mercier said:
I think is possible. We would need to see the riders who would participate. Next year probably Hesjedal will want win one more time, the Ag2r squad with Pozzovivo and Betancur, Movistar with Quintana and maybe Evans, Nibali or Fuglsang.
I think Quintana will be at the Tour with Valverde next year, providing it is reasonably mountainous. That's what Unzue indicated during the Vuelta. Capecchi, Szmyd and Visconti will head their Giro line-up I would guess.
 
Aug 23, 2012
1,114
1
0
Duartista said:
I think Quintana will be at the Tour with Valverde next year, providing it is reasonably mountainous. That's what Unzue indicated during the Vuelta. Capecchi, Szmyd and Visconti will head their Giro line-up I would guess.

Yes, i had forgot the two ex Liquigas. Probably Movistar signed them for the Italian calendar. The TDF is too hard for Quintana yet IMO. He suffered with the rhytm of the first week of the Vuelta, (said by him) also fell many times. I want to know what think Ryo about this.
 
Mar 31, 2010
18,136
6
0
Duartista said:
I think Quintana will be at the Tour with Valverde next year, providing it is reasonably mountainous. That's what Unzue indicated during the Vuelta. Capecchi, Szmyd and Visconti will head their Giro line-up I would guess.

yes I would think so too. quintana a protected man among valverde next year in the tour. giro could be cobo
 
Mar 31, 2010
18,136
6
0
Jason_Mercier said:
Yes, i had forgot the two ex Liquigas. Probably Movistar signed them for the Italian calendar. The TDF is too hard for Quintana yet IMO. He suffered with the rhytm of the first week of the Vuelta, (said by him) also fell many times. I want to know what think Ryo about this.

he suffered in the vuelta because of the incredible heat in the first week. he had only 1 racingday prior to the vuelta and he had been trianing in cold boyaca for months. next year he should come back for route du sud and then tour. tour is usually hot too. still he improved so much his skills in flat this year that next year I don't see too many problems. his real problem with first week suffering is that he has problems placing himself well in a peloton, he needs helpers for that. and he didn't crash anytime in this vuelta except in last few days
 
Oct 4, 2011
905
0
0
Quintana by a country mile as a pure climber. Able to stay with the best in the last week of the vuelta when noone else could, and kept for the last week by movistar. for gc its henao
 
Dec 27, 2010
6,674
1
0
Ryo Hazuki said:
he suffered in the vuelta because of the incredible heat in the first week. he had only 1 racingday prior to the vuelta and he had been trianing in cold boyaca for months. next year he should come back for route du sud and then tour. tour is usually hot too. still he improved so much his skills in flat this year that next year I don't see too many problems. his real problem with first week suffering is that he has problems placing himself well in a peloton, he needs helpers for that. and he didn't crash anytime in this vuelta except in last few days

When you consider how Movistar seemed to screw around with Quintana's race program (dropping him from the Giro last minute etc, going to the Vuelta with little racing), he's had a hell of a season.
 
Aug 23, 2012
1,114
1
0
If Coldeportes is invited to the Giro how would be the nine? Maybe something like this? Atapuma, Chaves, Duarte, Chalapud, Pantano, Suarez, Valencia... ?¿ Wait for your answer Ryo.
 
noddy69 said:
Quintana by a country mile as a pure climber. Able to stay with the best in the last week of the vuelta when noone else could, and kept for the last week by movistar. for gc its henao

A bit early to compare really. They have both only done 1 GT and Henao had a semi free role where Quintana was sacrificed for valverde.
 
Apr 10, 2011
4,818
0
0
uphillstruggle said:
A bit early to compare really. They have both only done 1 GT and Henao had a semi free role where Quintana was sacrificed for valverde.

And Henao wasn't sacrificed for Froome at Vuelta ?

Henao also did Giro this year ( 2 GT's ), where he got 9th place ;)