goober said:
Don't worry about the attacks. One of my students is writing a thesis and it actually includes this forum; hence, how I got here. The thesis actually has some great examples of delusionary/irrational sports fans (in spite of invalidating evidence) and how they use a public forum to satisfy their mindset.
All I can say is, I think your student should maybe look into the reasons why Lance chased down Filippo Simeoni in 2004 and then explain why so many longtime cycling fans dont like LA.
To me Lance is just like David Beckham, whose media profile outwieghs his footballing talents by about 100 to 1. I would never consider Beckham as one of the Top 5 footballers in the world at any stage of his career but ask anybody on the street to name a top footballer, they will inevitably name Beckham and I know that frustrates a lot of football fans.
Now Lance is way superior to Beckham in his sporting talent and achievements but is Lance far superior to Indurain or Merckx, no but look at their respective media profiles.
The US is a huge untapped market for cycling so every English speaking media outlet, bike related company etc is jumping on the Lance bandwagon trying to make a buck. An average cycling fan is not interested in profits for magazines or bike companies, they want to read and hear about the sport in general but all we get is Lance, Lance and more Lance all in the name of profiteering.
An example, a cycling magazine I read featured Lance on their front cover, either alone or shared on every issue from April to September in 2005. There was 20 pages on Lance in every issue bar one and a whole edition was dedicated to him following his Tour victory. This after 7 years of coverage being focused on Lance.
In the intervening years since his retirement, cycling media coverage became more widespread and balanced. Once Lance announced his comeback, its back to the old days with Lance articles everywhere and on the front covers every few issues. Surely people can understand why this would turn people against any athlete, even Tiger Woods or Roger Federer dont get this level of coverage in their respective sports. It is called over saturation.
If you want, you can direct your student to me and I will happily explain in detail why Lance is disliked by many.