Teams & Riders Tadej Pogačar discussion thread

Page 1488 - Get up to date with the latest news, scores & standings from the Cycling News Community.

Charlyghoul

BANNED
Jul 19, 2025
746
528
3,080
IIRC, Merckx raced in the 60s and 70s.
Merckx raced 13 WC RR, these are the winner nations:
Belgium - 5
Netherlands - 2
Italy - 4
Germany - 1
UK - 1

These are startlists from every WC RR Merckx won.



I'm not putting startlists from other years but as you can see, Belgium was heavily favored to win WC. Less nations and Belgium had clearly more riders than a lot of other nations.
You can't run away from this.

IMO PCS is a reliable source but if someone knows these startlists are incorrect, please tell me, I don't want to have an opinion based on incorrect facts.
Spain won 5 out of a possible ten world championships from 1995 to 2004, was it down to Spain being the dominant force in cycling or was it mostly because they had Freire?
 
Mar 20, 2022
13,259
18,014
22,180
Spain won 5 out of a possible ten world championships from 1995 to 2004, was it down to Spain being the dominant force in cycling or was it mostly because they had Freire?
But you can't just look to the winner. Look to the top10. It is very common to see 4 riders of one nation in the top10 and normally are from France, Italy or Belgium.
 
Mar 20, 2022
13,259
18,014
22,180
There way more cycling nations represented in the top10 after the specialization era. This is very obvious.
 

Charlyghoul

BANNED
Jul 19, 2025
746
528
3,080
But you can't just look to the winner. Look to the top10. It is very common to see 4 riders of one nation in the top10 and normally are from France, Italy or Belgium.
What about the top ten ?
3 in 67,
4 in 71,
2 in 74

When Van Looy won his two the French and Italians had strong teams, Van Looy won because he was the best one day rider there.
When Freire won his three there were 4 other spanish riders in the top 20 in 2004, in 1999 and 2001 there were none.
 
Oct 23, 2024
293
448
2,130
I think that charlyghoul just want this thread be full of comments and with even more pages so no one in the future will come even close too Pog's thread and that will make him GOAT here forewer. Also keeps something going on in most boring month where we can't see GOAT doing GOAT things.
 

Charlyghoul

BANNED
Jul 19, 2025
746
528
3,080
There way more cycling nations represented in the top10 after the specialization era. This is very obvious.
I will say again, if cycling is so much more specialised, why are there only two consistent riders in the tour?
The only other consistent rider over the last few years has been Adam Yates, a guy who’s never won a grand tour.
In Merckx era the contenders were much more consistent and were of a much higher calibre. The top ten was always stacked with tour winners or grand tour winners.

Think of it this way, in Merckx time there was a top ten of thoroughbred Gc racehorses, Merckx was the stallion.
Now there are two stallions, and a peloton of mules.
I know which is era is better overall.
 
Mar 20, 2022
13,259
18,014
22,180
What about the top ten ?
3 in 67,
4 in 71,
2 in 74

When Van Looy won his two the French and Italians had strong teams, Van Looy won because he was the best one day rider there.
When Freire won his three there were 4 other spanish riders in the top 20 in 2004, in 1999 and 2001 there were none.
Count how many riders from France, Belgium and Italy are in the top10 and compare with nowadays. You have your answer.
If you are trying to avoid my argument, there is no chance we will have a meaningful discussion.
 
Mar 20, 2022
13,259
18,014
22,180
I will say again, if cycling is so much more specialised, why are there only two consistent riders in the tour?
The only other consistent rider over the last few years has been Adam Yates, a guy who’s never won a grand tour.
In Merckx era the contenders were much more consistent and were of a much higher calibre. The top ten was always stacked with tour winners or grand tour winners.

Think of it this way, in Merckx time there was a top ten of thoroughbred Gc racehorses, Merckx was the stallion.
Now there are two stallions, and a peloton of mules.
I know which is era is better overall.
If we look to your argument, in your opinion Djokovic is not the GOAT of tennis
 

Charlyghoul

BANNED
Jul 19, 2025
746
528
3,080
Count how many riders from France, Belgium and Italy are in the top10 and compare with nowadays. You have your answer.
If you are trying to avoid my argument, there is no chance we will have a meaningful discussion.
The fact is that during Merckx era there were two Belgian winners, two Dutch winners, and three italian winners.
Hardly shows a Belgian dominance does it? It just shows Merckx’ dominance
 
Mar 20, 2022
13,259
18,014
22,180
The fact is that during Merckx era there were two Belgian winners, two Dutch winners, and three italian winners.
Hardly shows a Belgian dominance does it? It just shows Merckx’ dominance
Do you want me to show all monuments? Your argument will go out the window.
I already showed you results from MSR, GdL, PR, RVV and LBL.
I'm done today. Let's agree to disagree (once again).
 

Charlyghoul

BANNED
Jul 19, 2025
746
528
3,080
Do you want me to show all monuments? Your argument will go out the window.
I already showed you results from MSR, GdL, PR, RVV and LBL.
I'm done today. Let's agree to disagree (once again).
What monuments ?
There are great riders in every era. This era is not stronger in the worlds, you have dominant guys like Sagan (bit like Van Looy) or Pog (Merckx)

Then you have lower level guys like Rui Costa and Pedersen winning the worlds, they are much poorer winners than Adorni or Gimondi.

The tour is another ball game where it’s not comparable, the old era was much stronger here
 
  • Like
Reactions: Peyroteo94
Mar 20, 2022
13,259
18,014
22,180
What monuments ?
There are great riders in every era. This era is not stronger in the worlds, you have dominant guys like Sagan (bit like Van Looy) or Pog (Merckx)

Then you have lower level guys like Rui Costa and Pedersen winning the worlds, they are much poorer winners than Adorni or Gimondi.

The tour is another ball game where it’s not comparable, the old era was much stronger here
You know what monuments.

I must say I am pretty shocked with this. Eheheh
 

Charlyghoul

BANNED
Jul 19, 2025
746
528
3,080
I think if we look at results, comparing to other sports, he’s on about an Andy Murray level of all time, a bit below the true greats for the time being. I mean he can be better but he’s not there yet.

He has more talent than that of course, but we need to see results. I don’t want to sound harsh, but if he carries on moaning about retirement and fatigue, he can be the GOAT of the miserables, even above Andy.
 
Jul 8, 2017
2,275
2,960
17,180
I don't get the number of countries argument in regards to the level of field.
If in the 70's you've had 4 Italians, 3 Belgians and 3 french as top dogs and now you have the same number of riders, but from 10 different countries you're still it the same level of depth.
It's just that the field is more international. Hardly a proof of quality.

If we are going to compare something, we have to only compare the top 5-10 risers as they are the ones competing with each other. Is VDP better than De Vlaemink? Is Ocaña better than Vingegaard, is Evenepoel better than Gimondi (for example)?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Charlyghoul

Charlyghoul

BANNED
Jul 19, 2025
746
528
3,080
I don't get the number of countries argument in regards to the level of field.
If in the 70's you've had 4 Italians, 3 Belgians and 3 french as top dogs and now you have the same number of riders, but from 10 different countries you're still it the same level of depth.
It's just that the field is more international. Hardly a proof of quality.

If we are going to compare something, we have to only compare the top 5-10 risers as they are the ones competing with each other. Is VDP better than De Vlaemink? Is Ocaña better than Vingegaard, is Evenepoel better than Gimondi (for example)?
Exactly
 

Charlyghoul

BANNED
Jul 19, 2025
746
528
3,080
And I would say VDP is not better than De Vlaeminck, though it’s close in Roubaix/flanders

Vingegaard is close to Ocana, I’ll give Vingo a benefit of the doubt here, but it’s close

Remco is not better than Gimondi