Re:
staubsauger said:
We're talking about the Vuelta a Espana,where Tiralongo got a top 10 and Montfort got a top 5 finish on the general classification. Hence why the Tour of Spain isn't a proper grand tour. Gallopin very well might be able to reach a top 10 spot as well.
Come on, it's not the 80s anymore and while the Vuelta may still be the runt of the GC litter, it's pretty much established its position as one for many years now. While the Vuelta does still have the highest incidence of shock
winners, there's plenty of similarly out there results in the other GTs that show that surprising results like that are not exclusive to the Vuelta.
Pello Bilbao, Andrey Amador, Evgeni Petrov, Paolo Bettini, Dario Cioni, Yuri Trofimov and Bradley McGee have all top 10ed the Giro. Thomas de Gendt and Yaroslav Popovych have podiumed it. Are they all really such highly-rated GC threats that they are a clear cut above the kind of rider we're talking about at the Vuelta?
Admittedly in recent years the Tour is less fertile ground for outsiders, Thomas Voeckler, Cyril Dessel, Kim Kirchen, Christophe Le Mevel, Matthias Fränk, Laurens Ten Dam are examples you can point to but they tend to divide into two groups: Frenchmen who gained time in a breakaway and then defended an unexpected high GC position, and people who follow the "fall backwards as slowly as possible" modus operandi that Tiralongo did in the Vuelta, it's just that the preponderance of riders like Meintjes, Zubeldia, Valjavec and others for whom this has been their entire career and who are strong enough to defend a top 10 has meant fewer of the surprise riders staying in the top 10 by the end of the race.
Now, one factor at the Vuelta is that, especially in years where the World Championships is on a tough course, like 2009, 2013 and this year, preparation for the World Championships gives riders an easy 'out' for if they're not on form, so they will drop time and test their legs in other ways, such as Damiano Cunego being dropped in the Sierra Nevada stage in 2009, to go in the break the next day, when ordinarily he would probably have tried to defend his GC position, or Richie Porte dropping all manner of time for a week and then going in a break this week. And sure, Cobo and Horner are surprise winners, but that field Monfort was 5th in included Rodríguez, Scarponi, Antón and Nibali, it's just they all botched it completely; because of how important a top 10 at the Tour can be to a team's sponsors and budget, riders will probably be asked to protect that even if their form isn't right whereas in other races they'll drop time and hunt stages or secondary jerseys.
The abundance of riders protecting a top 10 at the Tour isn't so strong at the Giro or Vuelta and so you can find a few unexpected top 10s like Tiralongo's that emerge out of riders who just happen to be among the next group that comes in behind the GC contenders in each stage, but there is less sponsorship demand on the lower end of the top 10 in the Vuelta and owing to its place in the calendar, more erratic form among riders. After all, Tiralongo was 8th in 2009 but the 7 riders ahead of him were Valverde, Sánchez, Evans, Mosquera, Basso, Gesink, Rodríguez - quality riders all (that was also the best Gesink we ever saw and he would probably have podiumed without a crash on stage 19).