Who will win 2012 Tour de France

Page 27 - Get up to date with the latest news, scores & standings from the Cycling News Community.

Who will win 2012 TdF?

  • Ryder Hesjedal

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • Total voters
    0
  • Poll closed .
Mar 13, 2009
29,413
3,482
28,180
roundabout said:
you forgot imho...

And maybe you should check who actually voted for Wiggins

I was one of them, but not because of Wiggins not-so-aweseome climbing.

I just think the course lacks enough opportunities for the climbers to actually get enough time on Wiggins. Sure he probably isn't even the 6th best climber and willl suffer. But there's not enough suffering in this Tour where he loses so much time.. Even on Evans.

And the few MTF's that are there are a joke like La Toussiere... thats a wiggins climb
 
Jun 7, 2011
641
0
0
Maaaaaaaarten said:
Good enough to get third in a poor field, not to win a GT.

Off course he hadn't had an ideal preparation, crashing out of the TDF and all, but if he get's outclimbed by Cobo, Froome and Mollema he's in for a hell when he has to face Schleck, Samu, JVDB, Gesink, Nibali etc. all looking to gain time in the mountains. They will kill Wiggins in the mountains if he doesn't climb a whole lot better than last Vuelta.

Again, if they don't race too hard in the mountains Wiggins has a chance... but by no means has he showed anything in the mountains ever to make him a TDF contender. He only deserves to be mentioned because of the unbalanced amount of TT.

Yeah I mean he's lucky he didn't have to face JVDB at the Vuelta...
 
Jul 3, 2009
18,948
5
22,485
Magnus said:
But if they did use it they would get a 20 km flat run in to Bellegarde sur Valserine after the descent, which I think we can all agree isn't ideal.

Col de Richemond seems like a pretty fair battleground between a frontgroup and some chasers.

Artemare - GC - Gigniez - Biche - Richemond - BsV
 
Oct 23, 2011
3,846
2
0
Swede1 said:
Yeah I mean he's lucky he didn't have to face JVDB at the Vuelta...

JVDB lost over 3 minutes in the TT to Wiggins, which is more or less the ammount of time JVDB was behind Wiggins in the Vuelta.

JVDB is a better climber than Wiggins, just sayin'

Sure Wiggins'll probably be higher in the GC, but JVDB is one of many riders in this TDF who are better climbers and will be attacking Wiggins.
 
Sep 9, 2009
6,483
138
17,680
JVB is one of a select group of riders who are treated as serious contenders and actually have less pedigree and less palmares than Wiggins.
 
Oct 23, 2011
3,846
2
0
Waterloo Sunrise said:
Yeah, or Nibali - would have been crushed otherwise.

Clearly Vuelta 2011 was an anomaly in this regard; Nibali is a better climber than Wiggins. At least Nibali is a proven GT contender, unlike Wiggins, who never managed to get higher than 3rd, being beaten by Cobo and his own domestique.

At least Nibali has climbed this season, unlike Wiggins, so we know Nibali is climbing pretty well this season. While Wiggins was too busy winning crappy one week races without any serious mountains in them, while being outclimbed by Lieuwe Westra.
 
May 20, 2009
8,934
7
17,495
karlboss said:
3 form riders, wiggins, sanchez, nibali.
Tour suits wiggins more than the other 2 hence he's got loads of votes.

Evans, Menchov and Schleck would surely be outdoing him, if they'd shown something this season. But the first 2 have had health problems. The 3rd has been off, even further off than most expect for a one month wonder.

Few reminders:
- Wiggins hasn't shown GT mentality or performance against the best to date
- You forgot Gesink
- Nibali will have 2 teams working for him, the green and blue train :)
- Evans will be fit
 
Oct 23, 2011
3,846
2
0
Waterloo Sunrise said:
JVB is one of a select group of riders who are treated as serious contenders and actually have less pedigree and less palmares than Wiggins.

Just saying he's a better climber than Wiggins, not that JVDB is a better GC contender.
 
Aug 24, 2011
4,349
0
13,480
Maaaaaaaarten said:
JVDB lost over 3 minutes in the TT to Wiggins, which is more or less the ammount of time JVDB was behind Wiggins in the Vuelta.

JVDB is a better climber than Wiggins, just sayin'

Sure Wiggins'll probably be higher in the GC, but JVDB is one of many riders in this TDF who are better climbers and will be attacking Wiggins.

JVDB lost 2:01 in the ITT, gained 24 secs in the TTT (if you recall Sky had a nightmare TTT) and finished 3:06 down on Wiggins.

He lost 1:29 in non-TT stages, a little over half of that on Angrilu. (56 secs)
 
Oct 23, 2011
3,846
2
0
Catwhoorg said:
JVDB lost 2:01 in the ITT, gained 24 secs in the TTT (if you recall Sky had a nightmare TTT) and finished 3:06 down on Wiggins.

He lost 1:29 in non-TT stages, a little over half of that on Angrilu. (56 secs)

okay, my bad, sorry for screwing up the information.

My point still stands though, that JVDB is a better climber than Wiggins when in shape, take a look at the Tour where JVDB finished 5th.
 
Aug 29, 2011
239
0
9,030
Maaaaaaaarten said:
okay, my bad, sorry for screwing up the information.

My point still stands though, that JVDB is a better climber than Wiggins when in shape, take a look at the Tour where JVDB finished 5th.

Yeah but Wiggins was in fairly bad shape and appears to have grown a lot on both the ITT and the climbing since then. JVDB is a great climber, but doesn't seem motivated to train his time trialing enough; so in this tour I personally don't count him as a contender for a win (repeating his Top 5 is possible though). Last year's tour was a better chance, but unfortunately he fell before any serious riding was done :(
 
Jul 16, 2010
17,455
5
0
Swede1 said:
Yeah I mean he's lucky he didn't have to face JVDB at the Vuelta...

His injuries were slightly worse than those of Wiggins ;)
He also had less time to recover from them.
 
Jan 11, 2010
15,621
4,560
28,180
CasperVg said:
Yeah but Wiggins was in fairly bad shape and appears to have grown a lot on both the ITT and the climbing since then. JVDB is a great climber, but doesn't seem motivated to train his time trialing enough; so in this tour I personally don't count him as a contender for a win (repeating his Top 5 is possible though). Last year's tour was a better chance, but unfortunately he fell before any serious riding was done :(
VDB seems pretty serious about his TT training, and about his training in general... in fact I think there's quite a few more talented GC riders out there, but VDB makes up for it by hard work. And he already did quite well in the Algarve TT, so I guess we'll see in the Dauphine if he's really improved.

cineteq said:
It's a combination of hype and the overwhelming number of UK forum members - i suggested that wiggins percentage be multiplied by 0.3 to reflect accuracy ;)
Yeah, the Wiggo hype is becoming a bit ridiculous... yes, he's had great form so far this year, but what climbing has he really done? And I'm not convinced he's able to time trial as well as people think he will, in the Tour, and certainly in the final week of the Tour. There it's more about recovery. Look at the Tour where he got 4th, his final TT there wasn't bad, but certainly not great either.
 
Mar 13, 2009
29,413
3,482
28,180
El Pistolero said:
Not motivated to train his time trialing? He's obsessed with his time trial bike this season.

But apart from his Algarve ITT he didn't show much for it yet. Although in PV he was too afraid to take risks.
Then again JvdB has always been a peaker rather than a guy that's good all season long. He'll be there in the Tour if he doesn't fall.
 
Jul 16, 2010
17,455
5
0
theyoungest said:
VDB seems pretty serious about his TT training, and about his training in general... in fact I think there's quite a few more talented GC riders out there, but VDB makes up for it by hard work. And he already did quite well in the Algarve TT, so I guess we'll see in the Dauphine if he's really improved.

Yeah, I think exactly the same way about him.
 
Jul 16, 2010
17,455
5
0
Dekker_Tifosi said:
But apart from his Algarve ITT he didn't show much for it yet. Although in PV he was too afraid to take risks.
Then again JvdB has always been a peaker rather than a guy that's good all season long. He'll be there in the Tour if he doesn't fall.

The only time trials he has done are Algarve and Pais Vasco(which isn't an indicator of anything).
 
Apr 8, 2010
1,257
0
0
Ferminal said:
Artemare - GC - Gigniez - Biche - Richemond - BsV

But then they would be wasting Grand Colombier. Now it's set up to be the center of attention.
 
Apr 8, 2010
1,257
0
0
Do you seriously believe anybody would attack at Grand Colombier with Biche still to come?