Cookster15 said:
Contador:
Unable to reproduce in 2009 Tour form in subsequent Tours. Check.
No satisfactory explanation for his reduced level in 2010 Tour. Check.
His best GT performance was in the Giro - the Italians / Italian police are not as strict on doping as the French. Check.
Being able to stay with Rasmussen in 2007. Check.
Riding for Discovery, the home of Pharmstrong. Check.
Wins the 2008 Giro after sitting on a beach. Check.
Was taking a few days off before the 2008 Giro. Still training dude. No pro isn't training full time in April/May. That's a myth.
Cadel Evans in 2007? Best form he has ever had. Just as dirty as the rest. Sure Bottle suddenly found the best recovery in the final week, but Evans mitigated his time to Contador very well. Closet anyone has ever come to beating Contador. So again, another myth.
CONI??? Yeah, those Italian's sure love Spaniards!!!

Maybe you forgot about Valverde and the blood bag labelled 'Piti' from Puerto? Want me to go over the list of riders the Italians have been phone tapping and cracking down on? Take a look at Lampre's mediocre results...CONI are hard on doping. Just as hard as the French. So again, another myth.
Evans:
Never picked by a dirty team to ride the Tour. Check (eg Telekom, Ulrich, 2004).
Quoted by some prominent Pros as being 'the only clean GC rider' (e.g. Boonen). Check.
Riding for Lotto who couldn't replicate Popovich's or Horner's form at Astana. Check.
Twice World Cup mountain bike champ. Check.
Highest Vo2 max ever scored in the AIS (while still a mountain biker). Check.
Only GC contender to look like he was truly suffering in 2007 on climbs. Check.
Won the stage to Mount Wellington in 1999 while still a mountain biker and at just 22 years of age. Check.
Been covered on here before...many, many times. Porte went up Mt Wellington much faster than Evans.
Highest VO2max at the AIS? Another lie. Yes, a lie. 87 ml/min/kg...nice, but no Greg Lemond. Brett Aitken scored 92 ml/min/kg. Not the highest. Another myth.
Tommeke? Was banging 16 year old girls and hitting up so many lines of coke he thought it was constantly snowing in Belgium. Not a reliable source. Thor and Tom often say stuff like that. They also think LA was clean. Another myth.
Never picked by dirty teams to ride GT's? Another myth. Rode the Giro and on debut almost won the race. Evans not being picked comes down to his 'winning' personality as a young man. Short story, he was a tool. Europeans won't tolerate that kind of attitude, especially from an Aussie. Note Cadels form on the road and improved relations with team mates happened when he calmed down, relaxed and stopped being such a highly strung manic depressant. He's a loner. His personality cost him greatly in his early career...had nothing to do with being 'clean' or 'dirty'.
Ferrari took an interest in Evans when referred by Tony Rominger in his mountain bike days. It is well documented Evans impressed Ferrari further when he did some repeat mountain tests. This does not automatically make him guilty of doping. Evans performance on Mount Wellington in 1999 grabbed my attention too and well before I heard Phil Liggit say it.
There's very good reasons why Evan's was so revered especially by Aussie's or Anglophiles who for many years had no GC rider's to cheer for since Phil Anderson.
Yeah? Revered, because he was Aussie and the only one winning.
Who else were the rampant patriots Down Under to cheer for? Michael "I too visited Ferrari once' Rogers? The man had and still does have trouble staying upright. Same way that LA was revered. He was the biggest name from said country of origin and naturally you cheer for your own. Even more so when you're a part time fan.
No, Cadel Evans, is naturally very talented. But he is no cleaner than Contador. FFS he rides for Phonak reincarnated!!! He won the Tour, like they did with Floyd. Same owner, same DS. Same career best ever form. If you wanted to make a strong case for him being super talented, you'd have quoted Aldo Sassi who compared both Basso and Evans, he star pupils. But you clearly haven't heard what he said before he passed away.
One last thing. 2007 Tour de France. Third best rider in the race. Cadel in 2007 form, heck anyone in the top 10 would smack their current day self so hard in terms of a right proper beating, it would be hilarious. Clean...far from it.
I suggest you go get your jollies else where. Cadel is no cleaner than any of the top Spaniards. Be it Contador, Samu, Valverde, or Purito.
Hearing this stuff people are putting out is ridiculous. Evans gradually improved? Contador won the Tour at 24!!! Youngest winner since Ullrich FFS! Evans first raced it @28 years. The first time he stepped onto the podium he was 30 and a half years of age. Contador will be that age NEXT YEAR. FFS ladies, keep it real. Contador makes a very, very strong case for being naturally the best. He was up there young. Evans...oh that's right, Mt Wellington and the winning personality. Check, he always had it. True...Contador had more and showed it younger. Give it a rest.