l.Harm said:
Same defence two years ago. Btw Argentina's defence isn't that good. Even Spain got troubles at left and right back. And it's not like let's create some top defenders. Dutch football culture is not like the Italian one, where defending is more important. We became famous as football nation with an attacking style of play. Yes, then we had better defenders, now we don't have. We are a country with 16 million people, it already is a miracle we've such good players in the front. Just some bad luck at the back.
And such a bull**** about English second league. Some Dutchies play there who'll never reach this level. There you just need to be strong and tall, like that Irish defender

I just name Arjan de Zeeuw in the past, Glenn Loovens

He can't even play at Feyenoord.
Actually it's not that much of a surprise. It has much to do with the KNVB's [dutch national soccer association] deliberate strategy to 'produce' soccer players due to their involvement at all levels of soccer in the Netherlands; be it the training of coaches; player development; commitment to amateur and youth leagues; or team development.
Obviously it does help soccer is the most important sport in the Netherlands.
There are around 1.2m soccer players in the Netherlands and 480,000 youth players. You are bound to 'produce' talent. This is not to say that countries with the biggest populations don't have an overall edge, IF they manage to set up a similar system (i.e. US; China?; but then again, they don't (yet) have a soccer culture.) Organized club football starts at age 5; age 6 they play 4x4; age 7-9 7x7; age 11-19 11x11. They start scouting at age 11 and from then on scouted player will start playing for regional district teams. If you join a district team, your practice sessions probably go up from 1-2 times a week to 4-6 times and you get added time on the field during extra games. That's outside the availability of weekly/monthly summer camps for kids.
Especially important is the fact that the KNVB has regional and district coaches and coaching trainers, who can provide training and instructors to club trainers, to help them to another level. It also comes with a common 'dutch' style of play, and unfortunately, it doesn't emphasize the defensive qualities of a defender; a typical dutch defender should primarily be a player who can pass balls, think forward/move up a line, understand position changes, and as backs, act as a winger; offensive midfielder.
I don't mind 'total football'. I do mind the poor defensive skills. And let's not kid ourselves that, defensively, the dutch were better at the WC 2010.
Heitinga, I wouldn't trust one on one with anyone, not even in the English second league. In this EC (he played what 2x? only) he has left his man unmarked countless times, even during set pieces, he has provided poor cover for other defenders, and/or coaches badly when attackers make position changes. Mathijsen is so slow that if he doesn't stand 4m behind the attacker, he'll lose him no doubt, which means the defensive lines continues to walk back until the 16m, where any team can take pot shots at the goal.
It's no surprise the dutch play with 2 holding defenders, because when they don't most 'top' teams would walk right through their defense. I read somewhere Gomez had the ball 22s in total against the dutch... he scored twice. Against Portugal, when much of the team had been substituted for more offensive oriented players, you saw again how weak the defense was, in and of itself. They just can't cope on an individual or line level with attackers. They cover wrong, leave men unmarked, are too slow, communicate badly, walk back too much. I don't even know what they got right.
And then the self-inflicted wounds, if they are supposed to be football players first, or passing players, how often do they lose the ball when starting a play due to a bad pass to the midfield, after which they are totally out of position to stop a counter attack.
2Gregory van der Wiel (24)
3John Heitinga (28)
4Joris Mathijsen (32)
5Wilfred Bouma (34)
13Ron Vlaar (27)
15Jetro Willems (18)
21Khalid Boulahrouz (30)
You can't win a war with these guys and non of them is even remotely world class.
And don't get me wrong, I do realize that when the midfield or offense doesn't transition quickly enough, their defense will be badly exposed.