Giro Stage 9: Benevento – S.Giorgio del Sannio 215 kms

Page 24 - Get up to date with the latest news, scores & standings from the Cycling News Community.
Feb 3, 2015
284
0
0
Re: Re:

sultanofhyd said:
Jazasz said:
sultanofhyd said:
Jazasz said:
If anything it looked like Contador was the one who initiated the 'lets takes turns pulling and distance uran' arrangement. Riders work together all the time and its pretty much expected that when its time to sprint the cooperation is over. Its not like they were all taking turns and when it got to the end of Contadors pull Aru decided to launch a surprise attack.

Rewatch the sprint. This is exactly what happened.

No it was a sprint. There is no surprise factor in a sprint because everyone knows its a sprint.

No they don't because no one sprints for 12th place.

So why the next group was sprinting for 14th?
 
Jul 16, 2011
1,561
10
10,510
Re: Re:

sultanofhyd said:
No they don't because no one sprints for 12th place.

You do if you're a major GC contender when there's a major GC contender behind and another GC contender in the group who was rather reticent in cooperating beforehand. There was no sleight of hand in sprinting.
 
Jan 27, 2012
15,231
2,623
28,180
The Motorcycle incident probably prevented this stage from being top notch. Hope he makes it ok.

Anyway congrats to Tiralongo, another Astana superhuman.
 
May 12, 2015
345
0
0
Re: Re:

sultanofhyd said:
Jazasz said:
sultanofhyd said:
Jazasz said:
If anything it looked like Contador was the one who initiated the 'lets takes turns pulling and distance uran' arrangement. Riders work together all the time and its pretty much expected that when its time to sprint the cooperation is over. Its not like they were all taking turns and when it got to the end of Contadors pull Aru decided to launch a surprise attack.

Rewatch the sprint. This is exactly what happened.

No it was a sprint. There is no surprise factor in a sprint because everyone knows its a sprint.

No they don't because no one sprints for 12th place.

Aru does.

I've never seen anyone burn as big a bridge for just one stinking second.
 
Jul 20, 2010
118
0
0
This should put all the debates to rest I think. AC doesnt sound exactly pleased but maybe not too pissed either.

"I would have preferred to have ridden more conservatively from the final climb to the finish, but Aru asked me to work with him because Urán was behind us, and it was important to put time into him," Contador said. "We worked together, even if he sprinted to gain back a second, but I’m very happy with where I am after nine stages. I have the Maglia Rosa, and I have a rest day for my shoulder and legs to recover."

Aru sprinted with 100 meters remaining, hoping to pick up a few seconds on Contador, who led him in the GC by only four seconds. The Italian picked up one second, and is now only 3 seconds down in second place, with Porte third at 22 seconds.

“Right now it looks like it won’t be easy to take the pink jersey away from Contador,” Tiralongo said after the stage. “He’s a real champion, but there is still time. For us, it is important to concentrate on Fabio Aru. I was in the break group to support him, and then saw that it could work out for me.”

Contador was happy to have defended his lead, and called it “the most unusual stage I have ever experienced.”
 
Apr 3, 2009
12,645
8,554
28,180
Re:

sunnyIce said:
This should put all the debates to rest I think. AC doesnt sound exactly pleased but maybe not too pissed either.

"I would have preferred to have ridden more conservatively from the final climb to the finish, but Aru asked me to work with him because Urán was behind us, and it was important to put time into him," Contador said. "We worked together, even if he sprinted to gain back a second, but I’m very happy with where I am after nine stages. I have the Maglia Rosa, and I have a rest day for my shoulder and legs to recover.

He's always in the right head space, Contador. Said what he had to with Aru and moves on in public. Confirms it was Aru who requested help, confirms he didn't like the sprint after the agreement and is happy overall.
 
Feb 20, 2010
33,066
15,280
28,180
Re: Re:

Tank Engine said:
SeriousSam said:
There was also nothing wrong with what Benat did, although I suppose some fans would like to see riders not doing their best to win and instead subscribe to their views of honour and respect.

It was a perfectly valid tactic. You could almost see it coming. Reichenbacher learned a lesson, but he would have been mad at Benat.
Beñat could have shared a few relays though, he was bluffing well enough.

For a great example on this, look at stage 8 of the 2009 Tour. Astarloza, Casar, Luísle and Efimkin are away and are going to contest the stage win when Efimkin stops taking relays. The rest keep riding because they want to ensure the break stays away, but they get frustrated with the Russian. When he attacks, the other three are pissed and charge off to chase him down. Casar and Astarloza are relaying, Luísle comes through a few times and drives for Efimkin but is just too tired to take all of his turns and keeps yo-yoing. When he is in the right place when it's time for a relay, he pulls for a few seconds then backs off again. Casar and Astarloza therefore have no problem with LuLu because he's trying to help, but he's clearly spent. Therefore once the job in catching Efimkin is done, he stops helping out at the front, and they don't complain.

Then he attacks for the stage win and gets clear, because he'd been bluffing all along.

If Beñat had done the same act of being tired, but offered some half-hearted turns to help Reichenbach, there wouldn't have been anything like the same frustration when he jumped away and profited from the Swiss' work.
 
Jul 20, 2010
118
0
0
It will be great for the Giro if AC decides to put some serious hurt on Fabio. Will make for an entertaining GT, otherwise it looks like it will be going by script so far. But wonder if he will and maybe hurt his chances at the Tour by overextending.

And Tiro agrees, “Right now it looks like it won’t be easy to take the pink jersey away from Contador,” Tiralongo said after the stage.
 
Jan 4, 2011
6,229
241
17,880
Lol at that sprint from Aru. Really obvious that he was trying to gap Contador and Porte there. So silly after you ask Contador to cooperate :eek:
 
Jul 29, 2012
11,703
4
0
I don't think there's much wrong of aru to do it but at the same time it's understandable contador is upset.

Aru asks him to work together to distance Uran who isn't a real threat for Contador but he definitely is for aru who has a *** ITT.

So contador probably was like "yea i guess i can do some pulls to help you, doesn't matter for me either way that much."

And then aru clearly tries to take time on him with that move after contador just pulled. Aru can do whatever he wants but i don't think it was worth to make contador upset.
 
Mar 27, 2015
264
0
0
sagan has only 49 points?????? cav has 55???? what's happenig here? sagan has two first places, two seconds and a third place, why he isn't the leader?
 
Apr 16, 2009
17,600
6,854
28,180
Why did Contador have ice on his face? Was it because Aru slapped him on the face?

On a serious note Aru should not have done that. But at least the intensity of the race is becoming bigger and bigger and I like it.
 
Aug 31, 2012
7,550
3
0
Re: Re:

Libertine Seguros said:
Tank Engine said:
SeriousSam said:
There was also nothing wrong with what Benat did, although I suppose some fans would like to see riders not doing their best to win and instead subscribe to their views of honour and respect.

It was a perfectly valid tactic. You could almost see it coming. Reichenbacher learned a lesson, but he would have been mad at Benat.
Beñat could have shared a few relays though, he was bluffing well enough.

For a great example on this, look at stage 8 of the 2009 Tour. Astarloza, Casar, Luísle and Efimkin are away and are going to contest the stage win when Efimkin stops taking relays. The rest keep riding because they want to ensure the break stays away, but they get frustrated with the Russian. When he attacks, the other three are pissed and charge off to chase him down. Casar and Astarloza are relaying, Luísle comes through a few times and drives for Efimkin but is just too tired to take all of his turns and keeps yo-yoing. When he is in the right place when it's time for a relay, he pulls for a few seconds then backs off again. Casar and Astarloza therefore have no problem with LuLu because he's trying to help, but he's clearly spent. Therefore once the job in catching Efimkin is done, he stops helping out at the front, and they don't complain.

Then he attacks for the stage win and gets clear, because he'd been bluffing all along.

If Beñat had done the same act of being tired, but offered some half-hearted turns to help Reichenbach, there wouldn't have been anything like the same frustration when he jumped away and profited from the Swiss' work.
I agree that doing a little work would have been preferable for Beñat for the reasons you mention. That's distinct from the criticism usually levied at such tactics, which is that they violate some code of ethics, show a lack of class and courage etc. Not that I have a problem with that criticism, subscribing to what I think shows great character is one of the things that affects whether I root for a rider or root against him.

What I don't like is when people pass off one type of criticism (they don't like what the rider did, which I think is perfectly fine, I make such judgements all the time) as the other (what the rider did is bad for accomplishing his current and future objectives).
 
Mar 10, 2009
4,707
47
15,530
Re:

SafeBet said:
So Contador can go for the intermediate sprint and gain boni seconds but others can't try to gain seconds on him in a sprint finish?

It's Contador we're talking about. Don't forget the whole world is conspiring against him.
 
May 15, 2011
45,171
617
24,680
Re:

Escarabajo said:
Why did Contador have ice on his face? Was it because Aru slapped him on the face?

On a serious note Aru should not have done that. But at least the intensity of the race is becoming bigger and bigger and I like it.
He got hit by a camera (no joke)
 
Mar 10, 2009
4,707
47
15,530
Re:

Escarabajo said:
Why did Contador have ice on his face? Was it because Aru slapped him on the face?

On a serious note Aru should not have done that. But at least the intensity of the race is becoming bigger and bigger and I like it.

Why not? It's a race, not a business agreement.
 
May 27, 2014
2,432
86
11,580
Re:

Miburo said:
I don't think there's much wrong of aru to do it but at the same time it's understandable contador is upset.

Aru asks him to work together to distance Uran who isn't a real threat for Contador but he definitely is for aru who has a **** ITT.

So contador probably was like "yea i guess i can do some pulls to help you, doesn't matter for me either way that much."

And then aru clearly tries to take time on him with that move after contador just pulled. Aru can do whatever he wants but i don't think it was worth to make contador upset.


Suuuuuuuurreee.. Because Contador didn't want to put more time into Uran, the rider who was likely to pass him in GC after TT if not for today's stage forcing him to attack later in the race and spend energy instead of wheelsucking for rest of the Giro.

What a load of crap.
Contador worked because it benefited him as well, not because he was doing a favor for anyone