Moose McKnuckles said:
Remind me when Spartacus won a TdF mountain stage, outsprinting a future TdF champion.
Spartacus ever considered a team leader at the TdF? No? George was.
Hincapie went well above and beyond what a normal single-day stage racer could do unassisted by one of the most successful doping programmes in the cycling world.
Oh, and by the way, I hope you're not naive enough to think that Spartacus is doing this on Gatorade and Clif blocks.
Again... I believe EVERY rider is doped. I'm probably wrongly accusing a couple of guys with that assumption, but I'm betting I'll have a better batting average then if I believed every rider was clean.
I'm really looking for occasions where Hincapie was around in select groups helping Lance up a mountain. I know he won a mountain stage from a break, and I know he blew up the peloton a few times at the base of climbs, and I know he dropped back from breaks to help Lance up the road a few times... but in my (admittedly poor) memory, it was always other Postal/Discovery riders around with Lance when the group was winnowed down.
And yes... Pereiro did win the Tour. But while he was a very good climber... can we agree he wasn't elite?
And anyway, I think Oscar said it best after the race:
"I asked him [Hincapie] to work, as we had to collaborate to battle it out in a sprint - but he didn't. Sometimes it's not the strongest that wins."
He was strong enough to hang on Oscar's wheel and outsprint him. He didn't work the whole day... he was on the race leader's team and just hung on the back. Here are some snippets from CN's coverage of the stage:
"Down the wide open descent the now 10 front runners were still working hard, with Pereiro and the Rabobank riders driving the pace. Hincapie was just sitting on, acting as break police for his Discovery Channel leader, maillot jaune Armstrong."
"Hincapie looked good and was just marking everything, obviously under team orders not to work. There were now just six riders left up front: Pereiro, Boogerd, Hincapie, Caucchioli Brochard and Sevilla as the 7.5km climb at 7.9% grade commenced."
"Pereiro and Boogerd were doing the forcing up front, while Hincapie and Sevilla were sitting on."
While that showed George was a solid climber at that point... I'm not sure it showed he was particularly good. It's not like he was contributing to the work in the break and hung with Pereiro... he sat on all day and was able to go with a guy who was working hard all day long.
I guess my point is I never remembered thinking of Hincapie as a great climber... merely solid. That win led to him being considered a GC guy... but probably quite undeservedly so considering the circumstances.
I'm just trying to figure out what races (aside from that one) led people to think he was a mountain goat. Even with the dope... he just appeared average on the mountains to me.
Since the 2003 Alpe d'Huez was mentioned, I'm going to try to find some footage of that to see if he really did pull a big percentage of the way up the mountain as opposed to the early pull to decimate the group then release that I remember him doing in general terms.