The Cycling News forum is still looking to add volunteer moderators with. If you're interested in helping keep our discussions on track, send a direct message to
In the meanwhile, please use the Report option if you see a post that doesn't fit within the forum rules.
Thanks!
How so? 2023 was a cracking race. You're entitled to your opinion, but I can't reckon how any cycling fan would deem it "rancid." Similarly, 2022 was well raced, had great drama and sympathetic characters, so I'd rate it highly - although I acknowledge the palmares of Hindley are less impressive than most of our other GT winners.Hooray, a fourth rancid Giro in a row (assuming Pogacar isn't there) beckons. As I've said before, for every time the happy few do battle there are three where there's only one of them there and the race is a formality. That tradeoff is not worth it at all.
Do you really think it would have been a better with race with Dani, Geraint and Ben fighting it out? I certainly wouldn't. And just because Jonas decides to show up doesnt necessarily mean that Pog won't. Or Remco or Roglic for that matter.Hooray, a fourth rancid Giro in a row (assuming Pogacar isn't there) beckons. As I've said before, for every time the happy few do battle there are three where there's only one of them there and the race is a formality. That tradeoff is not worth it at all.
2023 was the worst Giro in existance (at least as since 2006-2007 when I started following the race). Pathetic race!How so? 2023 was a cracking race. You're entitled to your opinion, but I can't reckon how any cycling fan would deem it "rancid." Similarly, 2022 was well raced, had great drama and sympathetic characters, so I'd rate it highly - although I acknowledge the palmares of Hindley are less impressive than most of our other GT winners.
Wut???How so? 2023 was a cracking race. You're entitled to your opinion, but I can't reckon how any cycling fan would deem it "rancid." Similarly, 2022 was well raced, had great drama and sympathetic characters, so I'd rate it highly - although I acknowledge the palmares of Hindley are less impressive than most of our other GT winners.
Yeah, it bears no comparison with 2022 and 2023. But the fact that we didn't get to see Bernal's attack and raid on Giau probably somehow influences the conception of the race.2021 was pretty good in my opinion
Based on this year he doesn't need to train at all to win the giro (if Pog isn't there). Like literally just lay in bed till mid April. The giro itself should be fine base training with a handful of vo2 intervals and then he'll be ready for the le tour.IMHO this won't end the way it did for Pog. Jonas is a more fragile rider than Pogacar. Jonas is amazing but tends to peak for specific events and then not be so stellar.
I think he is already going to have a fight on his hands for the tour, and going to the giro puts that in jeopardy.
You can go back to the voting threads at the time to see what the forum thinks of both Giri. Spoiler alert: especially for the 2023 race, you're in a very small minority.How so? 2023 was a cracking race. You're entitled to your opinion, but I can't reckon how any cycling fan would deem it "rancid." Similarly, 2022 was well raced, had great drama and sympathetic characters, so I'd rate it highly - although I acknowledge the palmares of Hindley are less impressive than most of our other GT winners.
An uninspiring set of GC riders isn't a 100% guarantee of a boring GC battle. The winner being four levels above everyone else is.Do you really think it would have been a better with race with Dani, Geraint and Ben fighting it out? I certainly wouldn't. And just because Jonas decides to show up doesnt necessarily mean that Pog won't. Or Remco or Roglic for that matter.
I don't think I'm allowed to answer that question.So should we kill them?
It just comes down to people thinking Pogacar and Vingegaard doing 1km mountain sprints is the epicest thing ever but when others do it it's a disgrace.
Isn't this exactly what happened last year when Pog was rumored to ride the Giro and everybody was quick to say it wouldn't happen... Only for Pog to be confirmed later?Make sense, he is not the type of rider that do Giro-Tour double after have lost the Tour.
Is the tdf better than the giro because of the route or the riders who participate?Vegni is handling out big $ every year is so pathetic. Just make a great race again and use your ressources on that instead you fool
TouchéIs the tdf better than the giro because of the route or the riders who participate?
People love watching aliens do alien things.You voluntarily watched that this spring, there was just this dude 5 minutes ahead every time, which I guess was that much more exciting.
Vegni invested a lot in Pogacar because he would bring a lot of revenue. Who the fu## would want to see Geraint fuc#ing Thomas against Dani Martinez, O'Connor and Tiberi?
You don't know.As if that would have been the field without Pog there...
Who do you think Pog scared off, and what did they race instead?As if that would have been the field without Pog there...
I could see race organizers leaking something that never happened to create pressure onto Vingo. He's a one trick pony July racer, but cash and prospect of a giro title might at least interest him. I doubt it, though. His best chance at anything and everything possible is in July.