Well...if this happens it's for one reason and one reason only: Not winning with Carr.USA Today has an article saying it's certain Brady is going to the Raiders. While NFL.com is saying Derek Carr is trade bait, with the Raiders ready to dump him.
This caused me to do some looking, let's compare Derek Carr, 2019, to Tom Brady, 2019.
• In QBR, Carr was 62.2 (10th), while Brady was 53.7 (17th).
• In Passer Rating, Carr was 100.8 (9th), while Brady was 88.0 (18th).
• In completion %, Carr was 70.4 (2nd in league!), while Brady was 60.8 (27th).
• That last stat may make you think Carr was throwing a lot shorter passes, but that's not true either. Carr was throwing passes an average of 7.9 yards, versus just 6.6 for Brady.
• Tom threw 3 more TD's, but had a lower TD % (3.9 to 4.1 for Carr).
• The only other stat I can find of Tom's that was better was he threw for 4057 yards, versus 4054, a measly three yards, but threw the ball 100 more times to get those three yards.
Derek Carr is also 28 years old, arguably coming off his best year on a team with a poor defense, while Tom is 42 coming off a year on a team with one of the best defenses in NFL history.
I'm not saying Carr is going to have a hall of fame career, or that Tom won't be good next year, maybe the year after, but it seems to me the notion of dumping Carr to get Brady can only be rooted in selling tickets, or memorabilia and could put the Raiders in a hole for years and years to come.
The last two seasons with Gruden running the show and Carr starting all 32 games their record was a dismal 11-21 (2018/4-12 & 2019/7-9). Gruden should have had them in the playoffs by his 2nd year - so instead of firing Gruden, Carr would get the blame. Davis must think they can just plug in TB and they're SB bound this season. Lol. Chuckie should have been fired if he couldn't get this talented team to the playoffs or at the very least a winning record by his 2nd season (Shurmur only got two years).
Last edited: