All Pro, Pro Bowl, who cares! Starters are starters for a reason, they are the best that a team has at a given position. If a team has starters out, they won't b as good. Sometimes a team lucks out and a #2 ends up playing #1 level ball, but that is the exception not the rule.
Let's talk about exceptions for a second here: should Sam Darnold be in the MVP discussion? He was drafted as a QB 1, but has mostly played at a QB3 level until this year.
Let me rant a little more here.

I'm vomit stricken with all of the talk of the red zone (and some who refer to it as the red area...get a dermatologist)! Yes, I'll be the first one to say: "they need to score more 6s than 3s", but the closer the O gets to the end zone, the easier it is to defend. O coordinators should be doing a better job of designing plays from the 20+.