Because he’s been an elite game manager the last two seasons. The offense has only looked good for the whole game vs terrible defenses, otherwise it’s only for a couple drives to a half that they look good. They’ve been kept in the games due to their elite defense and special teams, and Mahomes more often than not wins the game at the end. Allen, Jackson, Burrow, Hurts, and Stafford could all have similar success while Goff, Love, Tua, Stroud, Lawrence, and Herbert could all make the playoffs and progress at a minimum. Last season offense was 15th in points and 11th in yards and this season isn’t much better at 11th in points and 13th in yards. The team kicks too many field goals but their elite defense stifles the opposing team.
Nonsense Shadow - your dislike for the
Gunslinger obscures the statistical evidence you're overlooking. You're correct on the defense - the Chiefs have an elite D that's going to keep them in games most of the time. But you still need an effective offense to score & win games, especially during crunch time when the chips are down.
Mahomes achieved
4000+ yds & 24+ TDs in each of his six seasons starting. 4000+ yds plus 24+ TDs passing are
benchmarks of what defines a good passing QB in the league. Less than dozen QBs have achieved this over the last 3 seasons - even with the 17 game schedule.
Less than half of all 1st rd QBs have a achieved a season with 4000+ yds & 24+ TDs. Last year Mahomes finished
6th in total passing yds throwing for 4183 & 27 TDs. Factor in his 389 yds rushing & you have 4572 yds total O (
269 average per game) --- that's an offensive machine! He was even better in the playoffs last year (4 games) with 1051 passing, 6 TDs, 141 rushing - 1192 total O or
298 average per game.
https://www.pro-football-reference.com/years/2023/passing.htm
Now let's look at 4th Qtr comebacks & game winning drives - a true benchmark of a great QB. Mahomes currently has
42 4th Qtr comebacks/game winning drives more than
any active QB except Rodgers, Stafford & Wilson! However, they have 19, 15 & 12 yrs in the league, respectively, vs Mahomes 7 yrs (and all are future HOF, btw).
Get Patrick Mahomes Career 4th quarter comebacks for regular season and playoff games on Pro-football-reference.com.
www.pro-football-reference.com
This season Mahomes is
7th in passing (3608 & 23 TDs). However, he has a career high
seven (7) 4th Qtr comebacks/game winning drives already this season & there still is a game or two to go! Like I said, the 4000/24 benchmark might be in jeopardy this year depending upon if he plays in the last two games of the season or just the one against Pittsburgh.
So, if you have a QB pumping out
4000+ yds & 24+ TDs routinely every season, you have an outstanding passing QB with good receivers (nothing new there). That's far from an "elite game manager." Lol. And if you have a QB with that kind of 4th Qtr comeback ability, you have an elite QB who's going to win you close games more often than not.