Thoughtforfood said:
I am taking Federal Income Tax Law right now, and can assure you that you have absolutely no idea of what you are talking about. None. You are so far off base that I quit reading the rest of it.
I will have to allow your tax law student mode to override my never filing a tax return using dozens of accountants, tax law in multiple countries, and as professional traveling athlete, and spokesperson/leader of a number of non-profits.
You may indeed understand how things work better than I do. I have close friends that work at Skadden and Sullivan and Cromwell. I train with them, often discuss cycling issues both on and off the bike.
Lance's problems are a frequent subject. The complexity of his tax return is mind numbing. Revised tax returns, errors and penalties are part of the game. Companies of all kinds are found to have errors in returns, along with mispayments and under payments involving huge sums of money. It happens throughout the tax year and years previous. There are criminal findings from time to time but for the most part it's an apology and a fine. restitution and things just move on. Companies try hard to be accurate but mistakes are made. And presumably the big firms probably screw up because of inaccurate data provided.
Somebody else brought up the point of offshore income exemptions (@110,000 exempt w some residency restrictions). Lance earns so much more than that per year the point of criminality for the misuse of 100k here or there can most times be concluded as a clerical error.
Most bike clubs and teams have some component of non-profit in my experience. The income that is generated from all of Lance's interests are massive. The bike racing part is minor. The selling of old shop clutter 8 or 10 years ago is smaller still. The possible payments to Ferrari and his companies may have some level of misuse of money earmarked for a charity instead of a performance consultant in Switzerland. I would hardly think it will land him in jail. Further it doesn't appear to have a great deal of impact on his fund raising all over the world. From a quick sample he is still in demand as a speaker and icon worldwide.
I think many posters are unaware of how many pro athletes have foundations/non profits that raise money and spend it for a myriad of causes.
Until a couple of years ago a pro racer I know had more than half of his house tax deferred for the use of a dog rescue charity. His mini suv was also primarily used for animal rescue activities even w the Thule racks on the roof. The US tax code is so complicated that there is room for dozens if not 100's of deductions done from software, a cert preparer to top notch accountants and lawyers.