Predict the Top 5 GC in Tour de France

Page 3 - Get up to date with the latest news, scores & standings from the Cycling News Community.
Aug 16, 2013
7,620
2
0
1. Contador
2. Quintana
3. Purito
4. Nibali
5. Henao

Froome will crash and abandon somewhere in the first week. Purito is underestimated by a lot of members here. He will play a big role this Tour.
 
May 28, 2015
3
0
0
Re: Re:

BlurryVII said:
Pricey_sky said:
1. Froome - providing he doesn't crash again he is the strongest, other than that perhaps the only weakness are those short, steep hilltop finishes in week 1.
2. Contador - in tremendous form, maybe by week 3 just paying the price of a Giro/Tour double.

You gotta hope AC's kinda screwed by the Giro, because If he is in "tremendous form" as you say, he ain't loosing lol regadless of Froome's shape.

You love Froome a lot. Everyone understood that a long while ago. Any fresh ideas?
 
Re: Re:

sultanofhyd said:
jmdirt said:
Contador
Nibali
Quintana
van Garderen
Someone we didn't think of will crack the top five and maybe even stand on the box.

Someone like this?

chris_froome__70325__64779.1411710301.255.331.jpg

I said someone we "didn't" think of. You know Zubeldia, or some young guy, or Segan...
 
Re: Re:

WheelofGear said:
Brullnux said:
WheelofGear said:
Majka has to be the most one of the most overrated riders in the world. How in any world is he better than Pinot, Nibali or Bardet? In 2013 he had a very good giro, 6th. In 2014 he should've improved, but didn't,finished behind Aru, Quintana. In the Tour somehow he pulled off 2 stages, that surspised me but at least one of them was from a breakaway. My prediction:
1.Quintana
2.Froome
3.Nibali
4.AC
5.Pozzo/Pinot
If Quintana loses little time in the opening week then he will do well. In Vuelta last year he looked good before crashing, on par with AC and stronger then Froome. Admittedly, both were off form but so was Quintana. Froome will lose time on some of the uphill sprints and in the stage to Pra-Loup, Cauterets and Stage 18. Nibali will lose time in any big MTF, but make strong attacks in the stages mentioned above. AC will be too tired in the third week from what has been a difficult, fast Giro. He will join Nibali's attacks but be too tired. Pinot probably for 5th, but Pozzovivo if he is in form will take 5th.

You're seriously dumb if you think "the big 4" all will finish in top 5, mr. Degenkolb-can-win-Fleche-Wallone newb.

AHHH! It was going along just fine and then the name calling started...
 
Aug 31, 2012
7,550
3
0
Re: Re:

Velolover2 said:
Jspear said:
Of course it's way to early to really say. If all come in top form:
1. AC
2. Froome
3. Quintana
4. Nibali
5. Pinot
There is no way that they all 4 are going to be in top 5. That's a more unlikely than the scenario that it's not on of the big 4 who is going to win.

The top 4, by virtue of having individually greater chances to win he Tour than anyone else, form the most likely combination of riders for the top 4 places. Though it is not likely that they will, it is more likely than the scenario where you replace one or more of their names by a different rider.

If it helps, think of golf. It's more likely than not that Rory doesn't win the next major. But Rory is more likely to win the next major than everyone else. The Big 4 for aren't likely to finish 1 to 4, but they are still the most likely group of riders to finish 1 to 4. Combinations involving other riders are even less likely.

Nonetheless, with his incredible showing in the Ardennes, with Tour having hilly stages and time bonuses and with one of the great injustices of cycling being that Alejandro hasn't been on the podium of the Tour yet, I feel compelled to predict:

1. Dawg
2. Contador
3. Valverde
4. Nibali
5. Quintana

I hope Contador wins, though.
 
Aug 4, 2010
11,337
0
0
I cant believe my eyes, so many people believe in Giro-Tour double, situation has changed here, I remember the general opinion was opposite :eek:..interesting ;)
 
Aug 16, 2013
7,620
2
0
Re: Re:

SeriousSam said:
Velolover2 said:
Jspear said:
Of course it's way to early to really say. If all come in top form:
1. AC
2. Froome
3. Quintana
4. Nibali
5. Pinot
There is no way that they all 4 are going to be in top 5. That's a more unlikely than the scenario that it's not on of the big 4 who is going to win.

The top 4, by virtue of having individually greater chances to win he Tour than anyone else, form the most likely combination of riders for the top 4 places. Though it is not likely that they will, it is more likely than the scenario where you replace one or more of their names by a different rider.

If it helps, think of golf. It's more likely than not that Rory doesn't win the next major. But Rory is more likely to win the next major than everyone else. The Big 4 for aren't likely to finish 1 to 4, but they are still the most likely group of riders to finish 1 to 4. Combinations involving other riders are even less likely.

Nonetheless, with his incredible showing in the Ardennes, with Tour having hilly stages and time bonuses and with one of the great injustices of cycling being that Alejandro hasn't been on the podium of the Tour yet, I feel compelled to predict:

1. Dawg
2. Contador
3. Valverde
4. Nibali
5. Quintana

I hope Contador wins, though.

Why is that an injustice? He has failed many times in the Tour because he isn't consistent (and good) enough as a climber. You don't deserve a podium because you are a great cyclist in general.
 
Re:

Arredondo said:
1. Contador
2. Quintana
3. Purito
4. Nibali
5. Henao

Froome will crash and abandon somewhere in the first week. Purito is underestimated by a lot of members here. He will play a big role this Tour.

Perhaps people don't know where to place him because of his season so far...he isn't the rider he used to be. I think his best bet would be to go for the KOM jersey or stage wins.
 
Aug 16, 2013
7,620
2
0
Re: Re:

Jspear said:
Arredondo said:
1. Contador
2. Quintana
3. Purito
4. Nibali
5. Henao

Froome will crash and abandon somewhere in the first week. Purito is underestimated by a lot of members here. He will play a big role this Tour.

Perhaps people don't know where to place him because of his season so far...he isn't the rider he used to be. I think his best bet would be to go for the KOM jersey or stage wins.

He still won Pais Vasco, and finished on the podium in LBL.

He isn't the master anymore of the steep climbs like he was in the years 2010-2013. But he's still a great climber, with a really good kick. And he's got a strong team.
 
Re:

ILovecycling said:
I cant believe my eyes, so many people believe in Giro-Tour double, situation has changed here, I remember the general opinion was opposite :eek:..interesting ;)
Yeah I noticed that too :p

Arredondo said:
1. Contador
2. Quintana
3. Purito
4. Nibali
5. Henao

Froome will crash and abandon somewhere in the first week. Purito is underestimated by a lot of members here. He will play a big role this Tour.
I agree re Purito, I forgot about him. I would have him 4th maybe ahead of Pinot. Valverde is not as good in France usually.
 
Re:

ILovecycling said:
I cant believe my eyes, so many people believe in Giro-Tour double, situation has changed here, I remember the general opinion was opposite :eek:..interesting ;)

It's quite interesting really. Basically Contador has been good enough in this Giro to convince many he's still the best. I'm actually on the opposite side of the argument though. I never doubted his ability, but I think the energy he's had to expend in the Giro will be to much for him.

Unfortunately we've not really had the top 4 race against each other without crashes to know who's truly the best. But I just don't believe Contador is enough above the other 3 to beat them with a Giro in his legs. And to be quite honest I don't think anyone should be that good. Remember the last guy who did the Giro-Tour double wasn't exactly a paragon of clean cycling.

As I said I think it's really hard to know who's the best right now. I think under perfect conditions in the high mountains it's probably Contador/Quintana > Froome > Nibali. But the gaps are very small. And considering Froome is the best in TT and Nibali seems most complete (descents/cobbles) and both of them have very strong teams it's nigh impossible to predict what will happen.

That being said, excluding crashes, I reckon it will be something like:
1. Quintana (the lack of time trials strongly favours Quintana).
2. Froome (in the end I think he's going to be the 2nd best climber considering Contador has a Giro in his legs).
3. Nibali (he won't lose that much in the mountains, and he could be higher if he takes time in odd stages).
4. Contador (I just think he'll be too tired to take the top 3, and of course he'll try to win, which could cost him time).
5. Rodriguez (the lack of TT's favours him as much as Quintana, as do the punchy stages, I just think he's to old to challenge the likes of Quintana).

Honestly though, I don't think anyone will really know until La Pierre Saint Martin at the earliest.