The Cycling News forum is still looking to add volunteer moderators with. If you're interested in helping keep our discussions on track, send a direct message to
In the meanwhile, please use the Report option if you see a post that doesn't fit within the forum rules.
Thanks!
He hasn't won the Vuelta. And the Tour is packed with the strongest GC contenders.Might make sense to consider riding the Tour in the 2024 season.
A podium spot is up for grabs. Or have folk on here already decided who the first three are. Anything can happen between now and the Tour, and even during the Tour. Maybe he could do a Carapaz, TGH, Hindley, or Remco and win against the odds in a GT again.He hasn't won the Vuelta. And the Tour is packed with the strongest GC contenders.
Yeah, but he has won the Tour. He needs the Vuelta on his palmares.A podium spot is up for grabs. Or have folk on here already decided who the first three are. Anything can happen between now and the Tour, and even during the Tour. Maybe he could do a Carapaz, TGH, Hindley, or Remco and win against the odds in a GT again.
I like how he hasn't given up hope of getting back to the top. Little by little, he's getting there, and I hope he progresses well throughout the season.
What do you know?For what happened to him, I would like to see him winning Vuelta even if it's almost impossible with Vingegaard there. However, another face of him would not like to see him winning Vuelta because a rider with his talent can't be in the same league as Merckx, Froome, Contador, Hinault, etc. Even Nibali shouldn't belong there.
He doesn't have the talent/capacity to be in the same league of Contador, Froome, etc. Not in a million years. Winning Giro, Tour and Vuelta is for legens of this sports, not riders like Bernal. Even if he didn't have that horrible crash, he would not be able to beat the likes of Pogi or Vingegaard. Even his Tour win was extremely lucky, specially after Froome's crash.What do you know?
You almost want a rider not to perform even though he has immense talent, but cannot accept it. What are you talking about?
Remember that he was the one who started this youth movement, not Pogacar!
Everyone who wins all three GT is a legend.He doesn't have the talent/capacity to be in the same league of Contador, Froome, etc. Not in a million years. Winning Giro, Tour and Vuelta is for legens of this sports, not riders like Bernal. Even if he didn't have that horrible crash, he would not be able to beat the likes of Pogi or Vingegaard. Even his Tour win was extremely lucky, specially after Froome's crash.
I can assure you that he has more talent than Froome!He doesn't have the talent/capacity to be in the same league of Contador, Froome, etc. Not in a million years. Winning Giro, Tour and Vuelta is for legens of this sports, not riders like Bernal. Even if he didn't have that horrible crash, he would not be able to beat the likes of Pogi or Vingegaard. Even his Tour win was extremely lucky, specially after Froome's crash.
Not ceilling/capacity. Froome was way better than Bernal in GT's.I can assure you that he has more talent than Froome!
You don't need million years.
Ok, but that was not the question.Not ceilling/capacity. Froome was way better than Bernal in GT's.
Even if he hadn't, Bernal would never be able to win what Froome won. Not remotely close.Ok, but that was not the question.
Bernal has had major physical set backs at very young age compare to Froome.
Sincere question: why? Is it the level of competition just being higher or is there something about three weeks that you anticipate Bernal no longer has the stamina for?I'm much less confident when it comes to GTs, but I hope he can make a top-5 again.
He did complete both GTs last season, which was probably an important step into what we are seeing now.I'm not sure yet if he can regain the necessary stamina.
5th in the Vuelta last year would mean beating Landa there. Possible (hopefully), but it's another step up in addition to what he already has done.
Winning Giro, Tour and Vuelta is for riders who manage to win Giro, Tour and Vuelta. Whether this is a sufficient or necessary condition to be considered a legend of the sport is just a matter of opinion.He doesn't have the talent/capacity to be in the same league of Contador, Froome, etc. Not in a million years. Winning Giro, Tour and Vuelta is for legens of this sports, not riders like Bernal. Even if he didn't have that horrible crash, he would not be able to beat the likes of Pogi or Vingegaard. Even his Tour win was extremely lucky, specially after Froome's crash.
If talent is related to big injuries, then yeah he doesn't but Bernal certainly has the innate talent on the level of those guys. The Tour win stuff is absolute bollocks anyway. Bernal was seen as one of if not the top favourites going in and was also seen as that for the Giro before he crashed in training and had to forgo the start there. He was also quite competitive early on in 2020 Tour even struggling with a back injury that would ultimately lead him to DNF the Tour and have to take months off the bike and spend large parts of the next year rehabbing and still having issues with itHe doesn't have the talent/capacity to be in the same league of Contador, Froome, etc. Not in a million years. Winning Giro, Tour and Vuelta is for legens of this sports, not riders like Bernal. Even if he didn't have that horrible crash, he would not be able to beat the likes of Pogi or Vingegaard. Even his Tour win was extremely lucky, specially after Froome's crash.