karlboss said:
Again I don't think this was a huge jump in form, just for the first time outside of a short TT we actually saw it.
I would tend to agree. You have to keep in mind that pre-cancer, pre-1999, he was inarguably a very strong (and very successful) one-day rider, well suited for the classics. Everything in his early career indicated that his future lay in these events.
The USPRO, Worlds, Fleche Wallone, San Sebastian, LBL, etc. all suggested that his success would be as a one-day rider. I think he had something like 10 one-day wins in 1993-94.
As far as this year goes, I would consider this a decent showing. Several online commentaries suggest he was somewhat active several times during the day (although this wasn't too evident on Versus' coverage), he managed to keep himself well-positioned for most of the day, and as has been said already, he did finish in the first large group.
The differences between The Ronde and the Tour are obvious. Without the need for recovery, an older rider should be able to stay competetive in a single day event, although The Ronde hits you where old legs typically don't fare well: constant, repetetive accelerations and short violent climbing efforts. It would be interesting to see, if he had to race again tomorrow, just how well the legs would feel.
Also, I think it should be noted that he did get gapped a couple of times, and that he finished in the same group as a 36 year old (37 in June) George Hincapie, but all-in-all it wasn't far from what I expected.