- Aug 5, 2009
- 15,733
- 8,298
- 28,180
Re: Re:
I saw on TV somewhere that the French ships are in sea trials or some of them that were ordered by the Russians but like you said the French said that they would be delaying delivery.
ToreBear said:movingtarget said:python said:Ukraine: un général français démonte le mythe de l'"invasion russe"
http://fr.sputniknews.com/international ... 00534.html
(in french)
Ukraine: A French General destroys the myth of the russian invasion
according to the article, the director of french military intelligence general christophe gomart accused the american intelligence of falsifying facts. specifically, speaking before one of the committees of the french parliament, he said russia was NEVER preparing to invade ukraine. he referred to some france's own sources. moreover, he basically hinted at the us abusing its leading role within nato while referring to the falsehood.
my comment on the news validity after some research:
the accusation, if true, is so sensational, that it required a validation...to start, the source of the article is NOT a genuine french-based media. therefore, attempting to find an independent confirmation, i googled 'christophe gomart' both in english and french...among the heap of irrelevant finds, i could find only the sputnik reprints with NONE pointing to a main stream source. this seemed strange, as the french media would go bananas if it had sniffed out the piece. finally, i came across this link (also in french):
http://www.dedefensa.org/article-en_pas ... _2015.html
in summary, if i understood it correctly, the link refers to a 8132-word document, a report of the parliamentary hearing where the general was questioned. it seems the general made those accusations indirectly, as if a slip of tongue, while answering a question by Frédéric Lefebvre, about the relations with nato.
iow, the sensational statement appears genuine. why the french main stream media passed it, is not clear to me.![]()
A Russian backed invasion is still a Russian invasion and who was in the coffins going back over the border ? Everyone knows that some of the fighters were Russian conscripts but of course it was not on Russian TV as usual. Some actually refused to go. Russian backed mercenaries and Russian soldiers not in Russian uniforms with Russian weapons sounds like an invasion to me. Putin has already admitted he had plans for Crimea before the **** hit the fan in Kiev. The French are selling arms to Russia and are playing a balancing act it seems.
The French are currently not selling arms to Russia, or more correctly not delivering. Though the French did deliver Catherine thermal sights to Russian tanks quite a few years back. I think it was back in the late 90s or something.
The article above is likely not correct. Sputniknews is a part of the Russian propaganda apparatus. They like to add a grain of truth, then you are not likely to find any way to corroborate that information. The French general probably said something, but Sputnink news used part of what he said, and added/removed for the desired effect. Had the situation been as presented by sputnik, some the French media would have followed it up.
In this case it's to invoke memories of the run up to the invasion of Iraq where the US was providing misleading satellite images to convince countries to join. The French had a national capability and could debunk it. The Germans were given the French info. The point for the Russians is to sow division among Nato/EU countries.
Otherwise you are correct. Additionally back in august when it looked like the "rebels" would loose, Russia intervened with regular units to change the balance of power.
Their current strategy is to recruit contract soldiers then assemble them into new units. Some conscripts have been pressured/tricked into signing as well. Though I don't think this is policy. Likely more about commanders struggling to fill quotas.
I saw on TV somewhere that the French ships are in sea trials or some of them that were ordered by the Russians but like you said the French said that they would be delaying delivery.
