HTC Colombia seasonScottyMuser said:I'd argue that *with* Cav's and Greipel's wins, HTC have been about the 5th best team. Wins at Britain, TDU and TOC are really just jokes - its the 1 day classics/semi clsssics, the week long tours that people actually regard as being top quality (P-N, DL, Suisse, Romandie, Pais Vasco, settimana lombarda, castilla leon, trentino, T-A, burgos etc) and the GTs that a team really should be judged on - and yes, I am deliberately leaving off the PT as the majority of that is a joke and should be scrapped. And in *those* races, HTC won very little outside of Cav's 8 stages. Yes, Martin et al won a few TTs - but thats not exactly the same as, say, Samu Sanchez winning Burgos. Having a think back, the only races of note that they won were eneco (Martin) and GW (Eisel), and eneco was so close to vuelta not many really turned up.
Without them, the results put them below katyusha definitely, below garmin, euskaltel, rabo, ciasee, OPL, Vacansoleil (in the races they entered), and maybe cervelo. Velits was a shock, and was their 1 good non-Cav result - but if we were to judge a team with 1 podium place, rabo had a more successful season by viurtue of their podium coming in the TDF, Caisse's Arroyo podium leapfrogs HTC. Katyusha defintiely had a better year - Rodriguez *alone* had a better year the HTC minus Cav/Greipel
Gts.
2 stages in the Giro
5 stages in the Tour - the most of anyone
5 stages in the Vuelta- the most of anyone + Green Jersey.
Resulting in 12 GT stages - the most of anyone.
Even without any GC placing this would be amazing. But no they didnt stop there, they got a Vuelta 2nd/3rd place with Velits.
PT stage races.
Tour Down Under - Greipel wins. Greipel 3 stages. Held Yellow jersey for whole race.
Romandie - Rogers 3rd. Rogers + Pinotti held yellow jersey for few days. Pinotti + Cav stage wins
Catalunia - Cav 1 stage
Criterium de Dauphine - TJVG 3rd
Tour de SUisse - Tony Martin 3 days in Yellow. Tony Martin 1 stage.
Tour de Pologne - Greipel 2 stages
Eneco Tour - TOny MArtin Wins. Greipel 2 stages. Tony Martin 1 stage. Yellow for 3 days.
Semi classics - Eissel GW
And California is good too and there they won and got 3 stages as well.
Outside GTs HTC featured in almost every pro tour stage race. 2 wins. 12 stages.
So what if they didnt feature in the classics. Their GT + stage races record crushes everyone else. 5th best team? your having a laugh.
______________________________________________________________
I notice your summary of who was the best teams you use the conditional a lot eg:
1 If the races they won dont count and the races they lost do count. - In that case yes they are without doubt the worst team. But sorry, the PT does exist and teams do send better riders towards race. You cant just conveniently label "joke" any race they do win.
2 If we count Burgos but not the TOC. Again yes that does diminish their achievements. But the TOc does count. So no dice.
3 "Velits was a shock"- SO what. Still counts.
4 "if we were to judge a team with 1 podium place, rabo had a more successful season by viurtue of their podium coming in the TDF, Caisse's Arroyo podium leapfrogs HTC" - But we are not judging it by 1 podium place. We are judging them on their whole season.
Rabo= Menchov tdf 3rd + Freire MSR and Gesink semi classic. No GT stage wins. No PT wins. 1 or 2 stages in stage races. Versus HTCs above mentioned GT podium. 12 gt stage wins. Gt green jersey. 2 Pt stage races.
Caisse = Arroyo podium. 2 gt stage wins. 1 stage race podium. A semi classic.
Here is what their main Challengers did.
Liquigas
Gts. 2 GT victories 1 podium. 3 gt stages Combined jersey.
SR 1 podium, 5 stages
Classics Absolute nada
Astana
Gts - 1 win. COntdor the big one. 1 stage Vino
Stage races. - Contador Paris Nice. (he won a few others but if you want to start counting Algarve or Trentino, then bring on Turkey and TOB) 3 stages/
Classics - Vino LBL. Contador FW podium.
Saxo
Gts - 1 TDF podium. 5 stages
STage races - Schleck Tour de Suisse. 5 stages
Classics - Cancellara super double.
No other team comes close.
But tbh, my post has kind of been a waste of time, because all i had to do was post this.
CQ Team Ranking 2010
1. [Usa] Team HTC - Columbia 11059
2. [Ita] Liquigas - Doimo 9740
3. [Den] Team Saxo Bank 9719
4. [Rus] Team Katusha 8650
5. [Ned] Rabobank 8268
I suppose you could say, " the Cq ranking isnt neccesarily exactly right" if it was close. But look at this. HTC crush Liqui and Saxo by over 400 points. Total domination. The best team of 2010. UNless you decide that all the races they won dont count
Check mate