veji11 said:Another element is how overdiagnosed ADHD is in the US compared to for example continental Europe...
keeponrollin said:veji11 said:Another element is how overdiagnosed ADHD is in the US compared to for example continental Europe...
ADHD is more frequently diagnosed in the US, because having the diagnosis, has certain benefits, for the school, & the student; & the teachers prefer students that are medicated, as they're easier to work with.
Yep, whether the diagnosis is masking doping in sports or not, allergy and asthma incidence are definitely on the rise in the world as a whole.Bolder said:Re Biles: I'm sure you'll find she's not the only gymnast with an ADHD diagnosis/exemption. ADD diagnosis is really squishy, and college and high school kids, late night lawyers etc. have been taking Ritalin for years to sharpen up and calm down.
Re the Williamses...et alors?
However, as the father of an asthmatic but athletic son, and an asthmatic wife, I can tell you it's more common than you think, and that if even 15-20 percent of the peloton has some form of asthma I wouldn't be shocked.
keeponrollin said:veji11 said:Another element is how overdiagnosed ADHD is in the US compared to for example continental Europe...
ADHD is more frequently diagnosed in the US, because having the diagnosis, has certain benefits, for the school, & the student; & the teachers prefer students that are medicated, as they're easier to work with.
ebandit said:could one get any?............less normal ..ok venus disagrees
but hearing suggestions that athletes have been 'smeared' by TUE details being
released..............'smearing' would only occur if TUEs were 'less honest'
Mark L
djpbaltimore said:I think TJ Quinn has made the best point of anybody. Criticizing an athlete for testing positive for something that they are allowed to take is not very logical.
T.J. Quinn @TJQuinnESPN 3h3 hours ago
T.J. Quinn Retweeted Neal Rogers
Amen. If you don't like the rules, discuss the rules. This shows no violation of the rules.
Ross Tucker has suggested that all TUEs be eliminated. I think that is extreme, but there is probably too much abuse of the system.
RobbieCanuck said:djpbaltimore said:I think TJ Quinn has made the best point of anybody. Criticizing an athlete for testing positive for something that they are allowed to take is not very logical.
T.J. Quinn @TJQuinnESPN 3h3 hours ago
T.J. Quinn Retweeted Neal Rogers
Amen. If you don't like the rules, discuss the rules. This shows no violation of the rules.
Ross Tucker has suggested that all TUEs be eliminated. I think that is extreme, but there is probably too much abuse of the system.
Except the WADA TUE has pretty tough requirements - latest as follows:
STANDARDS AND PROCESS FOR GRANTING TUE
S 4.0 Obtaining a TUE
4.1 An Athlete may be granted a TUE if (and only if) he/she can show that each of the following conditions is met:
a. The Prohibited Substance or Prohibited Method in question is needed to treat an acute or chronic medical condition, such that the Athlete would experience a significant impairment to health if the Prohibited Substance or Prohibited Method were to be withheld.
b. The Therapeutic Use of the Prohibited Substance or Prohibited Method is highly unlikely to produce any additional enhancement of performance beyond what might be anticipated by a return to the Athlete’s normal state of health following the treatment of the acute or chronic medical condition.
c. There is no reasonable Therapeutic alternative to the Use of the Prohibited Substance or Prohibited Method.
d. The necessity for the Use of the Prohibited Substance or Prohibited Method is not a consequence, wholly or in part, of the prior Use(without a TUE) of a substance or method which was prohibited at the time of such Use.
RobbieCanuck said:[quote All the above requires is a doctors note. Are WADA going to over ride the medical profession? I dont think so.
Anyway WADA came about simply as PR for the IOC to say they are fighting doping, see they have WADA, but in fact they are just fluff.
USADA CEO Travis Tygart said the athletes are being wrongly smeared.
"In each of the situations, the athlete has done everything right in adhering to the global rules for obtaining permission to use a needed medication," he said.
Benotti69 said:RobbieCanuck said:[quote All the above requires is a doctors note. Are WADA going to over ride the medical profession? I dont think so.
Anyway WADA came about simply as PR for the IOC to say they are fighting doping, see they have WADA, but in fact they are just fluff.
While I get your point I sincerely doubt a "doctor's note" is sufficient. It would require a full medical report for which the doctor is putting their reputation on the line. It has to be reviewed by the the TUE committee (TUEC) pursuant to the International Standards for Approval adopted by WADA and every anti doping agency in the world.
See S 5.2 of the WADA TUE process on the WADA website.
The review process requires the application to be reviewed inter alia by,
a. TUECs should include at least three physicians with experience in the care and treatment of Athletes and a sound knowledge of clinical, sports and exercise medicine.
I accept that the rule says "should" include and whether or not these TUECs do in fact only WADA, the ADAs, or International Federations or Major Event Organizers can tell us.
arcus said:@ Robbbiecanuck and Benotti69:
I read the guidelines, and they specifically state that TUE applications should be supported by objective evidence. Cited examples included radiologic imaging, pathology reports, copies of actual lab results, etc.
If an athlete applied for a TUE saying they need hGH because they had to have a benign pituitary neoplasm surgically resected (so no longer produce the peptide endogenously), a "doctors-note' would/should not be sufficient. They would need copies of MRI scans, operative-reports, pathology etc (you would hope!!)
The problem area is the cluster of conditions like asthma, ADHD, and tissue injury where the diagnoses are less clear-cut and susceptible to manipulation.
She's asthmatic and he probably has the newly discovered ilness of the champions, ADHD so let's give him a permanent TUE for speed.Brullnux said:Petra Kvitova and Jack Conger
TeflonDub said:New drop from fancybear.net
Wiggins and Froome.
Froome was suffering from a chill and was granted permission to use prednisolone on his way to winning the Tour of Romandy in Switzerland in April.
