• The Cycling News forum is still looking to add volunteer moderators with. If you're interested in helping keep our discussions on track, send a direct message to @SHaines here on the forum, or use the Contact Us form to message the Community Team.

    In the meanwhile, please use the Report option if you see a post that doesn't fit within the forum rules.

    Thanks!

Tadej Pogacar and Mauro Giannetti

Page 265 - Get up to date with the latest news, scores & standings from the Cycling News Community.
I wouldn't be able to tell how talented cause this kind of gap can only happen because of outdoping everyone harder than ever happened or because of motors.
This what you get when he is doing and he is physiological better than everybody else. We already have a lot of dopers, probably in a better doping program compared to his rivals (Indurain, LA, Froome, Contador) but the gap was way more leaner for their rivals. This gigantic gap is not explained only by doping, it can't be.
Pogacar was always a huge talent and he became an even better responder
 
This what you get when he is doing and he is physiological better than everybody else. We already have a lot of dopers, probably in a better doping program compared to his rivals (Indurain, LA, Froome, Contador) but the gap was way more leaner for their rivals. This gigantic gap is not explained only by doping, it can't be.
Pogacar was always a huge talent and he became an even better responder
You don't have data to prove he is physiological better than the other top guys.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Stablo and E_F_
You are joking, right? Del Toro won a World Tour stage at age 19 on his second-ever race day as a neo-pro. Hirschi has eight this season. Ayuso has placed in the top-five in two of his three Grand Tour-starts.
Pogacar was a TdF winner before turning 22 years old and had a podium in the Vuelta too. Are you really trying to compare Pogacar’s palmares and specially performances to all 3 I mentioned? Do you need to wait 3/4 years to understand I am right or do you really think Ayuso or Del Toro will win the Tour in the next 2 seasons?
 
We either are watching that once in a hundred years talent that is now so perfectly tuned and supported by so much money that the Merckx era will be nothing in comparison or we watch a fake freak show that make Lance look good in comparison. The second is a 1000x more likely but in either case pro cycling is doomed. The fact that it is yearly confronted with deadly accidents, even in official WC races makes it even worse.
 
I think I already pointed out your hypocrisy after the Tour but will do it again. When you hero was the reigning Tour champion you were indifferent regarding doping saying everybody does it but you suddenly changed into an anti-doping advocate since he lost. I'm curious what happens if Vingo wins the next years Tour: probably guys are back to level playing field and it's all fair again, right?
In 2023 I think it wasn't that implausible to assume there was a modicum of parity between Vingegaard and Pogacar. In 2024 there it actually is implausible to consider that there is a modicum of parity between Pogacar and anyone else in terms of doping.
 
Pogacar was a TdF winner before turning 22 years old and had a podium in the Vuelta too. Are you really trying to compare Pogacar’s palmares and specially performances to all 3 I mentioned? Do you need to wait 3/4 years to understand I am right or do you really think Ayuso or Del Toro will win the Tour in the next 2 seasons?

Firstly, this doesn't change the point of the comment to which you replied. It is true that Pogi only really started winning meaningful races after signing with UAE as a junior.

Secondly, how do you measure talent? Ayuso was one of the best juniors in the world and showed every bit as much promise as Pogi if not even more. The same goes for Del Toro.
 
Firstly, this doesn't change the point of the comment to which you replied. It is true that Pogi only really started winning meaningful races after signing with UAE as a junior.

Secondly, how do you measure talent? Ayuso was one of the best juniors in the world and showed every bit as much promise as Pogi if not even more. The same goes for Del Toro.
Talent means something between "whenever I cannot explain performance." and "whatever I want it to be"
 
If 2024 should tell the CN forum something, it's that I'm always right. It would then be wise to apply that to what I've been saying about the Combloux ITT for 15 months now. Pogacar dropped a turd in that one.

Sure Pogacar dropped a turd but OTOH Vingo was in 100% form during all stages of the Tour this year, right? JV did a miracle there and I'm far from certain they were at a "technological" disadvantage there.
 
In 2023 I think it wasn't that implausible to assume there was a modicum of parity between Vingegaard and Pogacar. In 2024 there it actually is implausible to consider that there is a modicum of parity between Pogacar and anyone else in terms of doping.
And while 2023 was fast, it wasn't obscenely faster than 2022.

This year, particularly since PdB, has in fact been obscene. Comical. Farcical.
 
Sure Pogacar dropped a turd but OTOH Vingo was in 100% form during all stages of the Tour this year, right? JV did a miracle there and I'm far from certain they were at a "technological" disadvantage there.
Vingegaard had clearly weaker days in there. Isola 2000. Superdevoluy. He really tended to burn really hard for 10 minutes and then fade after an initial effort a few times, TT included.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Stablo
Firstly, this doesn't change the point of the comment to which you replied. It is true that Pogi only really started winning meaningful races after signing with UAE as a junior.

Secondly, how do you measure talent? Ayuso was one of the best juniors in the world and showed every bit as much promise as Pogi if not even more. The same goes for Del Toro.
He was 19 when he joined UAE. Were you expecting him to win what race when he was 18 years old?
Why hirschi didn't become better than Pogacar if he was better than him as a junior?
 
  • Like
Reactions: pastronef