DFA123 said:
Ataraxus said:
DFA123 said:
Exactly this. GTs should absolutely be won by all rounders, but Quintana is an all rounder. His results in GT time trials since 2014 are (excluding prologue): 13th, 1st, 6th, 20th, 10th, 11th and today's result - 23rd. If you don't consider that as good enough for an all rounder, then you're basically excluding anyone under 60kg from ever winning a GT, because you can't do much better than that at his weight. Of course he's better at climbing, but the reason he can win GTs (and riders like Purito can't), is because he holds his own against the clock.
Quintana's TT record is as good as, if not better than Dumoulin's climbing record in GTs.
Please illustrate the bold sentence with examples. Please.
And please give me one excellent performance of Quintana in Flat GT TTs which can compare to Dumo's third place in BlockHaus.
If you cannot, please rethink and reread what you write out of wishful thinking.
Just look at their respective results. In case that is too challenging, I'll do the work for you. I listed Quintana's TT results while aiming for the GC.
Dumoulin's climbing results in high mountain stages while aiming for the GC of a Grand Tour are: 9th, 15th, 12th, 16th, 35th, 6th and 3rd. Very similar to Quintana's TT results. Dumoulin is no more of an all rounder than Quintana. One is much better at climbing, but can hold their own in TTs. One is much better at TTs, but can hold their own (possibly) in the high mountains. Dumoulin gained several minutes in the TT today, but he lost several minutes in the Vuelta in the mountains.
For an equivalent to Dumoulin on Blockhaus, how about Quintana in the 2015 Vuelta. 6th overall ahead of Thomas, LLS, Oliveira and several other noted time triallists.
If you want to talk numbers let's do them properly:
Tom D in GC aspiring Grand Tours:
Giro 2017 Blockhaus - 3
Vuelta 2015 Andorra - 9 (7 excluding break better than Nairo)
Vuelta 2015 stage 14 - 15 (9 excluding break)
.. stage 15 - 12
...stage 16 - 16 (8 excluding break)
the disastrous.stage 20 - 35 (25 excluding break)
NQ in GC aspiring Grand Tours :
Giro 2017 - 23
Vuelta 2016 - 11
Tour 2016 - 20
Vuelta 2015 - 6
Tour 2015 - 57
Disastrous Vuelta 2014 - 82
Giro 2014 - 13
Tour 2013 - 54
Do I need to average the numbers ?
And No. Nairo's 6th place in Burgos ITT is not the same with third in Blockhaus.
Firstly because 3< 6
and secondly because one is beating Nibali, Mollema, Zakarin, Krujswijk, Pozzovivo up one of the steepest climbs in the Giro and the other is beating G LLS and Oliveira who didn't have any GC aspirations whatsoever.