The Cycling News forum is still looking to add volunteer moderators with. If you're interested in helping keep our discussions on track, send a direct message to
In the meanwhile, please use the Report option if you see a post that doesn't fit within the forum rules.
Thanks!
maxmartin said:Haha hopefully Aru's success also means Astana Nibali's camp is doing very well!!!
SafeBet said:Who's Nibali? We want Fabio Aru at the TdF![]()
It is called tough love. And his performances has not been up to par this season.l.Harm said:the Inner Ring
@inrng
La Gazzetta reports Vincenzo Nibali got a letter in late April about "poor performance" signed by Astana boss Vinokourov
the Inner Ring @inrng 2 uur
@kylsie1 there's a backroom clash between staff over methods, signing up to the MPCC etc too
....
l.Harm said:the Inner Ring
@inrng
La Gazzetta reports Vincenzo Nibali got a letter in late April about "poor performance" signed by Astana boss Vinokourov
the Inner Ring @inrng 2 uur
@kylsie1 there's a backroom clash between staff over methods, signing up to the MPCC etc too
....
trevim said:It's lovely how team owners turn against their riders as soon as things start to go wrong. Tinkov and Contador last year, Vino and Nibali now? I wonder what the hell is Amadio doing with Basso![]()
I don't think a guy like Nibali needs someone to tell him that he's doing bad. Vino would be better off managing Andy Schleck or some guy that after DNF 100 races still claim that "sensations were good". Also, who sends letters?Vino attacks everyone said:I don't know how you would like it, but if a team/athlete performs badly would you want to tell them, or pretend that everything they are doing is great as if it was a football team for 8 year old girls?
trevim said:I don't think a guy like Nibali needs someone to tell him that he's doing bad. Vino would be better off managing Andy Schleck or some guy that after DNF 100 races still claim that "sensations were good". Also, who sends letters?![]()
rhubroma said:Nibali is in a very bad situation indeed. After the Ardennes flop he was sent a little letter signed by Vinokourov lamenting that his "performances have not been adequate."
The essence of the note was as follows: "We pay a lot, but we want corresponding results. We don't care about the motives, but those results that till now haven't been seen. Thus handle it, because, as such, things are not going well."
Thus has reported la Gazzetta dello Sport today.
Now I say if they hired Nibali to win the Tour, which they did, then Astana has gotten exactly what it deserves. Vinokourov and co. should have known that the best Nibali, no offense, can't dominate the best Contador, or best Froome, and not even the best Quintana. Consequently they made a poor investment, though that's not Nibali's fault. He is a Giro winner and Tour podium at best, which he has already achieved.
Nibali, for his part, is no doubt totally stressed, disillusioned and even furious, for which the strong arm tactic adopted by the Kazaks will probably only worsen his situation and theirs.
Then there is the tension between Beppe Martinelli and Aleksander Shefer over race programs, equipment and preparation. It is impossible for such disparate personalities and cultures to see eye-to-eye.
webbie146 said:Is it correct that Astana has hired a new guy this year for training plans, preparation and stuff?
Vino attacks everyone said:think so, can't remember a name though
webbie146 said:Is it correct that Astana has hired a new guy this year for training plans, preparation and stuff?
rhubroma said:Nibali is in a very bad situation indeed. After the Ardennes flop he was sent a little letter signed by Vinokourov lamenting that his "performances have not been adequate."
The essence of the note was as follows: "We pay a lot, but we want corresponding results. We don't care about the motives, but those results that till now haven't been seen. Thus handle it, because, as such, things are not going well."
Thus has reported la Gazzetta dello Sport today.
Now I say if they hired Nibali to win the Tour, which they did, then Astana has gotten exactly what it deserves. Vinokourov and co. should have known that the best Nibali, no offense, can't dominate the best Contador, or best Froome, and not even the best Quintana. Consequently they made a poor investment, though that's not Nibali's fault. He is a Giro winner and Tour podium at best, which he has already achieved.
Nibali, for his part, is no doubt totally stressed, disillusioned and even furious, for which the strong arm tactic adopted by the Kazaks will probably only worsen his situation and theirs.
Then there is the tension between Beppe Martinelli and Aleksander Shefer over race programs, equipment and preparation. It is impossible for such disparate personalities and cultures to see eye-to-eye.
webbie146 said:Is it correct that Astana has hired a new guy this year for training plans, preparation and stuff?
hfer07 said:bottom line is:
can La Gazzetta be trusted?
rhubroma said:What kind of a question is that? That La Gazzetta fabricated the story? On this point, which newspapers can be trusted? Only those not Italian? Is that what you are getting at?
During the Giro the RAI commentary mentioned that Aru's third place saved Martinelli's position within Astana (or rather that if Aru didn't podium, Martinelli would have been fired).
Now I immediately thought then that it must be connected to Astana's being unsatisfied with Nibali's results in 2014. The letter has now demonstrated this beyond any doubt.
Nibali probably thought he needed to move to a non-Italian team to step up to another level, as Basso did when he left Fassa-Bartolo for CFC. Yet the two riders and situations are completely different and, aside from his Giro victory, the decision has not been fortuitous.