offbyone said:
Accomplished he is and in quite a diversified manner. But I think there is good reason for the focus on that Giro. So much of his road racing career was focused on having success in a grand tour. Despite all the promise he showed and annual hype, the repeated and consistent failures seemed to be reality. But then in 2012 he did it in fine style and not just the tour, the season. It was an overwhelming win and the way he performed during the tour and season was such a stark contrast to his historical accomplishments on the road at least, that skepticism is only natural. After all those failures, it was hard to believe and so we all watched for the success to be backed up by a repeat performance or at least a competitive one. But since he won that GT he has either pulled out of races for various reasons (personal, team decisions,etc)....or there was that one Giro that he quit because he couldn't ride in the rain. So there you have it.
Obviously, the guy is legit as he keeps winning stuff, but I still have to think that GT win was a once in a blue moon ride for him and the stars aligned only that once for him. Unfortunately, we will never know if he never tries. To date, the only one he really did was that Giro he failed in. I really would like to see him just ride any grand tour again for the win. It is hard not to believe that the course of this up coming Giro isn't another perfect one for him. So if he rides it and quits after the time trial or only rides it for the time trial, then I will be very disappointed.
What are you talking about? Cycling in a parallel universe?
So much of his road racing career was focused on having success in a grand tour.
So much? Unless you mean focus on prologues, focusing on having success there (but failing), that's just completely wrong. 2002 FdJ til before the Giro 2009 there was ZERO focus on success in a GT. Even in 09, some attempts to win prologues, some whining when Contador, a GT rider, won a prologue, something about that being not normal, that such guys win prologues, then a little first mountain test in the Giro 09 managed a senstational stage for his prior results to Alpe di Siusi. Then the Tour with a surprising 4th
2010 focus on the TdF: Failed completely
2011 focus on the TdF, BUT, unlike in 10, trying to get results before, which he did. And then crashed out of the TdF, got 3 in the Vuelta.
2012: TdF, won it.
2013: Focus on the Giro, failed.
So you could say he has had 4 years of GT GC focus. Not "so much of his career"
Despite all the promise he showed and annual hype, the repeated and consistent failures seemed to be reality.
Promise he showed? None til July 09. There he did. Annual hype and repeated failures, you realize he "failed" twice, 2010 and 2011. And 2011 was not even a real failure, crash out of the TdF, then podium the Vuelta, thus confirming his TdF 09. And the hype, ok, depends where I guess, if you're from the UK, probably yes, in other places not so much, at least until 2012.