Serhiy Honchar finished 2nd at the 2004 Giro d'Italia behind Damiano Cunego. He has beaten Gilberto Simoni however by reeling him back in up towards Bormio 2000. He also was ahead of Popovych, already before the Ukrainian cracked completely.
Almeida finished 3rd at the 2024 Giro d'Italia behind grandpa Thomas and Primoz Roglic who was far from his best, apart from the Lussari MTT! Almeida reached the podium in a piss poor Giro d'Italia due to Tao Geoghegan Hart crashing and Evenepoel falling ill.
He has zero acceleration, hence can't attack and create a gap in the mountains. He can only limit his losses and hope Lady lucks adds up to reach a podium.
Ayuso got a 3rd place at the 2022 Vuelta a Espana aged 19. Benefitted from Roglic crashing out and Rodriguez injuring himself of course. But Ayuso himself struggled with Covid-19 ahead of the La Pandera stage. At the 2024 Vuelta a Espana he finished 4th after a nearly complete lackluster season that only started in late April. So he never reached full sharpness and neither development in that season. Still won on Albulapass at the Tour de Suisse however. If it wasn't for Jumbo playing shenanigans with the entire Vuelta field however by placing gc Kuss into that breakaway, Ayuso would have been 3rd again. So he kinda got the podium in 2022 already that he should have gotten in 2023. Despite Almeida being a shitty teammate like always on Angliru.
So no, Almeida doesn't deserve leadership at the 2024 Vuelta a Espana. At least not on a team like UAE. If he goes to a team like Israel or Tudor and becomes their Top 5 general classification rider, then yes. But not on UAE.
Ayuso himself however better starts praying that this Covid-19 infection won't harm him any longer. Because yes, he has to be fully prepared and needs to fulfill his potential this fall at the Vuelta a Espana. Otherwise he no longer can be described as a potential Grand Tour winner for 2025. He needs to turn this mishap into his luck now.
Almeida however isn't a potential Grand Tour winner. Neither was Serhiy Honchar!
A lot of words to expose a clear anti-Almeida bias.
Sure he has no punch, but you say that Almeida got into the Giro 2023 podium because it was a piss poor edition and that had Lady luck on his side but what about the Giro 2022 when Almeida was on route to the podium before dropping out with covid?
Plus I will go as far as to stay that if Almeida had been the UAE leader in this year's Giro he would have likely won the race given the very high level that he showed both in Tour de Suisse and now in the Tour de France where he sits 4th overall, being well ahead of Ayuso before he dropped out sick.
You also have the facts wrong regarding the Vuelta 2022, Ayuso was not sick during Sierra de la Pandera, he had instead a puncture that cost him some 20/30 seconds and his covid diagnosis was known earlier on that week (stage 11). And while finishing on a Grand Tour podium at 19 (almost turning 20) is impressive he was still minutes behind Evenepoel in the overall unlike Almeida in last year's Giro.
For me both Ayuso and Almeida are very talented riders that deserve GT leadership as long as Pogačar is not riding however in this Tour, Almeida was showing a higher level than Ayuso and at least he was not hanging on the back when he had to work for Pogačar (so much for the shitty teammate...)