MarkvW said:
I don't think so. Go back in time and reflect on the context. The settlement was effected three months before Floyd's grand public revelation. I think Lance and the Trekkies knew that hurtful discovery was out there and that a settlement would make it all go away.
I acknowledge that Greg might not have known about Floyd's turnabout in advance, but Lance's side surely did.
Better argument seems to be that Trek was more motivated to settle than Floyd.
What do you think? (This is a civil invitation)
Thank you. I will accept your invitation.
I don't think that you are countering my point, if I understand your point. I think that even if Lance and Trek were seeking to get ahead or squash what they knew was brewing, that doesn't mean that Mr. Lemond recovered much of anything in real terms, as it relates to the losses he had for the business. I could certainly be wrong, but it seems to me that the losses he suffered by losing his agreement with Trek (and certainly, he gained in his initial sale of his name), coupled with the cost of the litigation itself, probably mitigated a lot of the gains he made.
But as you rightly point out, we will actually never know, which is why I think that this topic is not super helpful to any of us who would like to see cycling a much cleaner sport. I think you are counted among those people, and I know hog, digger, mew, dave, and lots of other people would all love to see that end. I also think we all know the unlikelihood of that happening, so we fight here for no good purpose. (And I reflect upon my contributions in that statement as unfavorable)
Thanks for offering a civil discourse. I truly appreciate that.
EDIT: And by "losing his agreement with Trek," I mean that in terms of lost future earnings, which were almost certainly not recovered because of the speculative nature (because obviously, Trek's attorneys wouldn't have bought into something they knew they'd win if it went to court.) Those are also certainly not his only losses as it relates to the agreement. They may have paid, but I am willing to bet that when you subtract all of the actual numbers, he didn't come out all that great, if at all. And, certainly I could be wrong.