Walkman said:Well then we disagree on Gilberts form.
Didn't you see him attacking all over the place to get the green jersey? He (and other of course) made a two hour long breakaway attempt wich forced HTC to chase so hard that the average speed during those two hours was over 46 km/h! He came second in a sprint only beaten by Cav and at the same time he was climbing probably better than ever? I'd say he was easily in top shape.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=player_detailpage&v=nBUq8cCHMCw#t=2151s
As I stated, I'm not so sure about Gilbert.